PasteQuill

"Do Schools Kill Creativity?" TED Talk Transcript

TEDYouTube captionsEnglish (en)427 segmentsWatch on YouTube

0:27

Good morning. How are you?

0:29

(Audience) Good.

0:31

It's been great, hasn't it?

0:33

I've been blown away by the whole thing.

0:35

In fact, I'm leaving.

0:37

(Laughter)

0:43

There have been three themes running through the conference,

0:46

which are relevant to what I want to talk about.

0:48

One is the extraordinary evidence of human creativity

0:53

in all of the presentations that we've had

0:55

and in all of the people here;

0:57

just the variety of it and the range of it.

1:01

The second is that it's put us in a place

1:03

where we have no idea what's going to happen

1:05

in terms of the future.

1:07

No idea how this may play out.

1:10

I have an interest in education.

1:11

Actually, what I find is, everybody has an interest in education.

1:16

Don't you?

1:17

I find this very interesting.

1:19

If you're at a dinner party, and you say you work in education --

1:23

actually, you're not often at dinner parties, frankly.

1:25

(Laughter)

1:29

If you work in education, you're not asked.

1:32

(Laughter)

1:35

And you're never asked back, curiously. That's strange to me.

1:39

But if you are, and you say to somebody,

1:41

you know, they say, "What do you do?"

1:43

and you say you work in education,

1:45

you can see the blood run from their face.

1:47

They're like, "Oh my God. Why me?"

1:48

(Laughter)

1:51

"My one night out all week."

1:52

(Laughter)

1:55

But if you ask about their education, they pin you to the wall,

1:58

because it's one of those things that goes deep with people, am I right?

2:02

Like religion and money and other things.

2:05

So I have a big interest in education, and I think we all do.

2:10

We have a huge vested interest in it,

2:11

partly because it's education that's meant to take us into this future

2:15

that we can't grasp.

2:16

If you think of it,

2:18

children starting school this year will be retiring in 2065.

2:25

Nobody has a clue,

2:26

despite all the expertise that's been on parade for the past four days,

2:30

what the world will look like in five years' time.

2:33

And yet, we're meant to be educating them for it.

2:35

So the unpredictability, I think, is extraordinary.

2:37

And the third part of this is that we've all agreed, nonetheless,

2:41

on the really extraordinary capacities that children have --

2:46

their capacities for innovation.

2:49

I mean, Sirena last night was a marvel, wasn't she?

2:51

Just seeing what she could do.

2:53

And she's exceptional, but I think she's not, so to speak,

2:59

exceptional in the whole of childhood.

3:02

What you have there is a person of extraordinary dedication

3:04

who found a talent.

3:06

And my contention is, all kids have tremendous talents,

3:08

and we squander them, pretty ruthlessly.

3:11

So I want to talk about education,

3:13

and I want to talk about creativity.

3:14

My contention is that creativity now is as important in education as literacy,

3:21

and we should treat it with the same status.

3:23

(Applause)

3:24

Thank you.

3:26

(Applause)

3:30

That was it, by the way. Thank you very much.

3:32

(Laughter)

3:34

So, 15 minutes left.

3:36

(Laughter)

3:39

"Well, I was born ... "

3:41

(Laughter)

3:45

I heard a great story recently -- I love telling it --

3:47

of a little girl who was in a drawing lesson.

3:50

She was six, and she was at the back, drawing,

3:52

and the teacher said this girl hardly ever paid attention,

3:55

and in this drawing lesson, she did.

3:56

The teacher was fascinated.

3:58

She went over to her, and she said, "What are you drawing?"

4:01

And the girl said, "I'm drawing a picture of God."

4:04

And the teacher said, "But nobody knows what God looks like."

4:07

And the girl said, "They will in a minute."

4:10

(Laughter)

4:21

When my son was four in England --

4:24

actually, he was four everywhere, to be honest.

4:26

(Laughter)

4:28

If we're being strict about it, wherever he went, he was four that year.

4:31

He was in the Nativity play. Do you remember the story?

4:34

(Laughter)

4:35

No, it was big, it was a big story.

4:37

Mel Gibson did the sequel, you may have seen it.

4:39

(Laughter)

4:41

"Nativity II."

4:42

But James got the part of Joseph, which we were thrilled about.

4:46

We considered this to be one of the lead parts.

4:49

We had the place crammed full of agents in T-shirts:

4:52

"James Robinson IS Joseph!"

4:53

(Laughter)

4:54

He didn't have to speak, but you know the bit where the three kings come in?

4:58

They come in bearing gifts, gold, frankincense and myrrh.

5:00

This really happened.

5:02

We were sitting there, and I think they just went out of sequence,

5:05

because we talked to the little boy afterward and said,

5:07

"You OK with that?" They said, "Yeah, why? Was that wrong?"

5:10

They just switched.

5:11

The three boys came in, four-year-olds with tea towels on their heads.

5:15

They put these boxes down, and the first boy said, "I bring you gold."

5:18

And the second boy said, "I bring you myrrh."

5:20

And the third boy said, "Frank sent this."

5:22

(Laughter)

5:35

What these things have in common is that kids will take a chance.

5:38

If they don't know, they'll have a go.

5:42

Am I right? They're not frightened of being wrong.

5:45

I don't mean to say that being wrong is the same thing as being creative.

5:49

What we do know is, if you're not prepared to be wrong,

5:53

you'll never come up with anything original --

5:55

if you're not prepared to be wrong.

5:57

And by the time they get to be adults, most kids have lost that capacity.

6:02

They have become frightened of being wrong.

6:04

And we run our companies like this.

6:06

We stigmatize mistakes.

6:08

And we're now running national education systems

6:10

where mistakes are the worst thing you can make.

6:13

And the result is that we are educating people

6:16

out of their creative capacities.

6:19

Picasso once said this, he said that all children are born artists.

6:23

The problem is to remain an artist as we grow up.

6:26

I believe this passionately, that we don't grow into creativity,

6:30

we grow out of it.

6:31

Or rather, we get educated out of it.

6:34

So why is this?

6:37

I lived in Stratford-on-Avon until about five years ago.

6:39

In fact, we moved from Stratford to Los Angeles.

6:42

So you can imagine what a seamless transition this was.

6:45

(Laughter)

6:47

Actually, we lived in a place called Snitterfield,

6:49

just outside Stratford,

6:50

which is where Shakespeare's father was born.

6:53

Are you struck by a new thought? I was.

6:55

You don't think of Shakespeare having a father, do you?

6:58

Do you?

6:59

Because you don't think of Shakespeare being a child, do you?

7:02

Shakespeare being seven?

7:03

I never thought of it.

7:04

I mean, he was seven at some point.

7:06

He was in somebody's English class, wasn't he?

7:08

(Laughter)

7:15

How annoying would that be?

7:17

(Laughter)

7:24

"Must try harder."

7:26

(Laughter)

7:30

Being sent to bed by his dad, to Shakespeare, "Go to bed, now!"

7:33

To William Shakespeare.

7:34

"And put the pencil down!"

7:36

(Laughter)

7:37

"And stop speaking like that."

7:38

(Laughter)

7:42

"It's confusing everybody."

7:43

(Laughter)

7:48

Anyway, we moved from Stratford to Los Angeles,

7:54

and I just want to say a word about the transition.

7:56

Actually, my son didn't want to come.

7:58

I've got two kids; he's 21 now, my daughter's 16.

8:00

He didn't want to come to Los Angeles.

8:03

He loved it, but he had a girlfriend in England.

8:06

This was the love of his life, Sarah.

8:09

He'd known her for a month.

8:11

(Laughter)

8:12

Mind you, they'd had their fourth anniversary,

8:15

because it's a long time when you're 16.

8:17

He was really upset on the plane.

8:19

He said, "I'll never find another girl like Sarah."

8:21

And we were rather pleased about that, frankly --

8:24

(Laughter)

8:32

because she was the main reason we were leaving the country.

8:35

(Laughter)

8:41

But something strikes you when you move to America

8:43

and travel around the world:

8:44

every education system on earth has the same hierarchy of subjects.

8:48

Every one. Doesn't matter where you go.

8:50

You'd think it would be otherwise, but it isn't.

8:52

At the top are mathematics and languages, then the humanities.

8:55

At the bottom are the arts. Everywhere on earth.

8:58

And in pretty much every system, too, there's a hierarchy within the arts.

9:02

Art and music are normally given a higher status in schools

9:05

than drama and dance.

9:06

There isn't an education system on the planet

9:08

that teaches dance every day to children

9:10

the way we teach them mathematics.

9:12

Why?

9:13

Why not?

9:14

I think this is rather important.

9:16

I think math is very important, but so is dance.

9:18

Children dance all the time if they're allowed to, we all do.

9:21

We all have bodies, don't we? Did I miss a meeting?

9:24

(Laughter)

9:27

Truthfully, what happens is, as children grow up,

9:29

we start to educate them progressively from the waist up.

9:32

And then we focus on their heads.

9:34

And slightly to one side.

9:37

If you were to visit education as an alien

9:39

and say "What's it for, public education?"

9:42

I think you'd have to conclude, if you look at the output,

9:44

who really succeeds by this,

9:46

who does everything they should,

9:48

who gets all the brownie points, who are the winners --

9:50

I think you'd have to conclude the whole purpose of public education

9:54

throughout the world

9:55

is to produce university professors.

9:57

Isn't it?

9:58

They're the people who come out the top.

10:00

And I used to be one, so there.

10:02

(Laughter)

10:06

And I like university professors,

10:08

but, you know, we shouldn't hold them up

10:10

as the high-water mark of all human achievement.

10:13

They're just a form of life.

10:15

Another form of life.

10:16

But they're rather curious.

10:18

And I say this out of affection for them:

10:19

there's something curious about professors.

10:22

In my experience -- not all of them, but typically -- they live in their heads.

10:25

They live up there and slightly to one side.

10:28

They're disembodied, you know, in a kind of literal way.

10:31

They look upon their body as a form of transport for their heads.

10:35

(Laughter)

10:41

Don't they?

10:42

It's a way of getting their head to meetings.

10:44

(Laughter)

10:50

If you want real evidence of out-of-body experiences, by the way,

10:53

get yourself along to a residential conference of senior academics

10:57

and pop into the discotheque on the final night.

10:59

(Laughter)

11:02

And there, you will see it.

11:03

Grown men and women writhing uncontrollably, off the beat.

11:08

(Laughter)

11:10

Waiting until it ends, so they can go home and write a paper about it.

11:14

(Laughter)

11:16

Our education system is predicated on the idea of academic ability.

11:20

And there's a reason.

11:21

Around the world, there were no public systems of education,

11:24

really, before the 19th century.

11:27

They all came into being to meet the needs of industrialism.

11:30

So the hierarchy is rooted on two ideas.

11:32

Number one, that the most useful subjects for work are at the top.

11:37

So you were probably steered benignly away from things at school

11:40

when you were a kid,

11:41

things you liked,

11:42

on the grounds you would never get a job doing that.

11:44

Is that right?

11:46

"Don't do music, you're not going to be a musician;

11:48

don't do art, you won't be an artist."

11:50

Benign advice -- now, profoundly mistaken.

11:53

The whole world is engulfed in a revolution.

11:55

And the second is academic ability,

11:57

which has really come to dominate our view of intelligence,

12:00

because the universities design the system in their image.

12:03

If you think of it,

12:04

the whole system of public education around the world is a protracted process

12:07

of university entrance.

12:09

And the consequence is that many highly talented,

12:11

brilliant, creative people think they're not,

12:13

because the thing they were good at at school

12:16

wasn't valued, or was actually stigmatized.

12:18

And I think we can't afford to go on that way.

12:20

In the next 30 years, according to UNESCO,

12:23

more people worldwide will be graduating through education

12:26

than since the beginning of history.

12:28

More people.

12:29

And it's the combination of all the things we've talked about:

12:32

technology and its transformational effect on work,

12:35

and demography and the huge explosion in population.

12:37

Suddenly, degrees aren't worth anything.

12:40

Isn't that true?

12:41

When I was a student, if you had a degree, you had a job.

12:44

If you didn't have a job, it's because you didn't want one.

12:47

And I didn't want one, frankly.

12:50

(Laughter)

12:51

But now kids with degrees are often heading home

12:55

to carry on playing video games,

12:57

because you need an MA where the previous job required a BA,

13:00

and now you need a PhD for the other.

13:02

It's a process of academic inflation.

13:04

And it indicates the whole structure of education is shifting beneath our feet.

13:07

We need to radically rethink our view of intelligence.

13:10

We know three things about intelligence.

13:12

One, it's diverse.

13:13

We think about the world in all the ways that we experience it.

13:16

We think visually, we think in sound, we think kinesthetically.

13:19

We think in abstract terms, we think in movement.

13:21

Secondly, intelligence is dynamic.

13:24

If you look at the interactions of a human brain,

13:27

as we heard yesterday from a number of presentations,

13:30

intelligence is wonderfully interactive.

13:32

The brain isn't divided into compartments.

13:34

In fact, creativity --

13:36

which I define as the process of having original ideas that have value --

13:40

more often than not comes about

13:42

through the interaction of different disciplinary ways of seeing things.

13:47

By the way, there's a shaft of nerves that joins the two halves of the brain,

13:51

called the corpus callosum.

13:52

It's thicker in women.

13:54

Following off from Helen yesterday,

13:56

this is probably why women are better at multitasking.

13:59

Because you are, aren't you?

14:01

There's a raft of research, but I know it from my personal life.

14:04

If my wife is cooking a meal at home, which is not often ...

14:09

thankfully.

14:10

(Laughter)

14:13

No, she's good at some things.

14:14

But if she's cooking, she's dealing with people on the phone,

14:17

she's talking to the kids, she's painting the ceiling --

14:20

(Laughter)

14:21

she's doing open-heart surgery over here.

14:23

If I'm cooking, the door is shut, the kids are out,

14:26

the phone's on the hook,

14:27

if she comes in, I get annoyed.

14:29

I say, "Terry, please, I'm trying to fry an egg in here."

14:32

(Laughter)

14:39

"Give me a break."

14:40

(Laughter)

14:42

Actually, do you know that old philosophical thing,

14:44

"If a tree falls in a forest, and nobody hears it, did it happen?"

14:48

Remember that old chestnut?

14:49

I saw a great T-shirt recently, which said,

14:52

"If a man speaks his mind in a forest, and no woman hears him,

14:56

is he still wrong?"

14:57

(Laughter)

15:05

And the third thing about intelligence is,

15:07

it's distinct.

15:09

I'm doing a new book at the moment called "Epiphany,"

15:11

which is based on a series of interviews with people

15:14

about how they discovered their talent.

15:15

I'm fascinated by how people got to be there.

15:18

It's really prompted by a conversation I had with a wonderful woman

15:21

who maybe most people have never heard of, Gillian Lynne.

15:24

Have you heard of her? Some have.

15:25

She's a choreographer, and everybody knows her work.

15:28

She did "Cats" and "Phantom of the Opera."

15:30

She's wonderful.

15:31

I used to be on the board of The Royal Ballet, as you can see.

15:34

(Laughter)

15:36

Gillian and I had lunch one day. I said, "How did you get to be a dancer?"

15:39

It was interesting.

15:41

When she was at school, she was really hopeless.

15:43

And the school, in the '30s, wrote to her parents and said,

15:46

"We think Gillian has a learning disorder."

15:48

She couldn't concentrate; she was fidgeting.

15:50

I think now they'd say she had ADHD.

15:52

Wouldn't you?

15:53

But this was the 1930s, and ADHD hadn't been invented at this point.

15:57

It wasn't an available condition.

15:59

(Laughter)

16:03

People weren't aware they could have that.

16:05

(Laughter)

16:07

Anyway, she went to see this specialist.

16:11

So, this oak-paneled room, and she was there with her mother,

16:15

and she was led and sat on this chair at the end,

16:17

and she sat on her hands for 20 minutes,

16:19

while this man talked to her mother

16:21

about all the problems Gillian was having at school,

16:23

because she was disturbing people, her homework was always late, and so on.

16:27

Little kid of eight.

16:28

In the end, the doctor went and sat next to Gillian and said,

16:31

"I've listened to all these things your mother's told me.

16:34

I need to speak to her privately.

16:36

Wait here. We'll be back. We won't be very long,"

16:38

and they went and left her.

16:41

But as they went out of the room,

16:42

he turned on the radio that was sitting on his desk.

16:45

And when they got out of the room,

16:47

he said to her mother, "Just stand and watch her."

16:49

And the minute they left the room,

16:52

she was on her feet, moving to the music.

16:54

And they watched for a few minutes, and he turned to her mother and said,

16:58

"Mrs. Lynne, Gillian isn't sick.

17:00

She's a dancer.

17:03

Take her to a dance school."

17:04

I said, "What happened?"

17:06

She said, "She did. I can't tell you how wonderful it was.

17:09

We walked in this room, and it was full of people like me --

17:11

people who couldn't sit still,

17:14

people who had to move to think."

17:17

Who had to move to think.

17:18

They did ballet, they did tap, jazz; they did modern; they did contemporary.

17:22

She was eventually auditioned for the Royal Ballet School.

17:25

She became a soloist; she had a wonderful career at the Royal Ballet.

17:28

She eventually graduated from the Royal Ballet School,

17:31

founded the Gillian Lynne Dance Company,

17:33

met Andrew Lloyd Webber.

17:34

She's been responsible for

17:35

some of the most successful musical theater productions in history,

17:38

she's given pleasure to millions,

17:40

and she's a multimillionaire.

17:41

Somebody else might have put her on medication and told her to calm down.

17:45

(Applause)

17:53

What I think it comes to is this:

17:55

Al Gore spoke the other night

17:57

about ecology and the revolution that was triggered by Rachel Carson.

18:02

I believe our only hope for the future

18:04

is to adopt a new conception of human ecology,

18:08

one in which we start to reconstitute our conception

18:10

of the richness of human capacity.

18:13

Our education system has mined our minds

18:16

in the way that we strip-mine the earth for a particular commodity.

18:20

And for the future, it won't serve us.

18:22

We have to rethink the fundamental principles

18:25

on which we're educating our children.

18:27

There was a wonderful quote by Jonas Salk, who said,

18:29

"If all the insects were to disappear from the Earth,

18:34

within 50 years, all life on Earth would end.

18:38

If all human beings disappeared from the Earth,

18:41

within 50 years, all forms of life would flourish."

18:45

And he's right.

18:47

What TED celebrates is the gift of the human imagination.

18:51

We have to be careful now that we use this gift wisely,

18:55

and that we avert some of the scenarios that we've talked about.

18:59

And the only way we'll do it is by seeing our creative capacities

19:02

for the richness they are

19:04

and seeing our children for the hope that they are.

19:07

And our task is to educate their whole being,

19:10

so they can face this future.

19:11

By the way -- we may not see this future,

19:14

but they will.

19:15

And our job is to help them make something of it.

19:18

Thank you very much.

19:19

(Applause)