PasteQuill

Veritasium Electricity Misconception Transcript

VeritasiumYouTube captionsEnglish (en)374 segmentsWatch on YouTube

0:00

This video was sponsored by Caséta by Lutron.

0:03

Imagine you have a giant circuit

0:06

consisting of a battery, a switch, a light bulb,

0:09

and two wires which are each 300,000 kilometers long.

0:13

That is the distance light travels in one second.

0:16

So, they would reach out half way to the moon

0:19

and then come back to be connected to the light bulb,

0:22

which is one meter away.

0:24

Now, the question is,

0:25

after I close this switch,

0:27

how long would it take for the bulb to light up.

0:30

Is it half a second,

0:31

one second,

0:32

two seconds,

0:34

1/c seconds,

0:35

or none of the above.

0:37

You have to make some simplifying assumptions

0:39

about this circuit,

0:40

like the wires have to have no resistance,

0:42

otherwise this wouldn't work

0:43

and the light bulb has to turn on immediately

0:46

when current passes through it.

0:48

But I want you to commit to an answer

0:50

and put it down in the comments

0:52

so you can't say,

0:53

oh yeah I knew that was the answer,

0:55

when I tell you the answer later on.

0:59

This question actually relates to how electrical energy

1:02

get from a power plant to your home.

1:05

Unlike a battery,

1:07

the electricity in the grid

1:08

comes in the form of alternating current, or AC,

1:11

which means electrons in the power lines

1:13

are just wiggling back and forth.

1:15

They never actually go anywhere.

1:18

So, if the charges don't come from the power plant

1:21

to your home,

1:22

how does the electrical energy actually reach you?

1:27

When I used to teach this subject,

1:29

I would say that power lines

1:30

are like this flexible plastic tubing

1:33

and the electrons inside are like this chain.

1:36

So, what a power station does,

1:38

is it pushes and pulls the electrons back and forth

1:42

60 times a second.

1:44

Now, at your house,

1:45

you can plug in a device, like a toaster,

1:48

which essentially means

1:49

allowing the electrons to run through it.

1:52

So when the power station pushes and pulls the electrons,

1:55

well, they encounter resistance in the toaster element,

1:59

and they dissipate their energy as heat,

2:03

and so you can toast your bread.

2:05

Now, this is a great story,

2:06

I think it's easy to visualize,

2:07

and I think my students understood it.

2:09

The only problem is, it's wrong.

2:13

For one thing,

2:14

there is no continuous conducting wire

2:16

that runs all the way from a power station to your house.

2:20

No, there are physical gaps,

2:22

there are breaks in the line,

2:24

like in transformers

2:25

where one coil of wire is wrapped on one side,

2:28

a different coil of wire is wrapped on the other side.

2:30

So, electrons cannot possibly flow

2:32

from one the other.

2:34

Plus, if it's the electrons

2:36

that are carrying the energy

2:38

from the power station to your device,

2:41

then when those same electrons

2:42

flow back to the power station,

2:44

why are they not also carrying energy

2:47

back from your house to the power station?

2:50

If the flow of current is two ways,

2:53

then why does energy only flow in one direction?

2:58

These are the lies you were taught about electricity,

3:01

that electrons themselves have potential energy,

3:05

that they are pushed or pulled

3:06

through a continuous conducting loop

3:08

and that they dissipate their energy in the device.

3:13

My claim in this video

3:14

is that all of that is false.

3:17

So, how does it actually work?

3:22

In the 1860's and 70's,

3:24

there was a huge breakthrough

3:26

in our understanding of the universe

3:27

when Scottish physicist, James Clerk Maxwell,

3:30

realized that light is made up

3:33

of oscillating electric and magnetic fields.

3:36

The fields are oscillating perpendicular to each other

3:39

and they are in phase,

3:41

meaning when one is at its maximum,

3:43

so is the other wave.

3:45

Now, he works out the equations

3:47

that govern the behavior of electric and magnetic fields

3:50

and hence, these waves,

3:52

those are now called Maxwell's equations.

3:55

But in 1883,

3:57

one of Maxwell's former students, John Henry Poynting,

4:00

is thinking about conversation of energy.

4:02

If energy is conserved locally in every tiny bit of space,

4:07

well, then you should be able to trace the path

4:10

that energy flows from one place to another.

4:13

So, think about the energy that comes to us from the sun,

4:16

during those eight minutes when the light is traveling,

4:19

the energy is stored and being transmitted

4:22

in the electric and magnetic fields of the light.

4:26

Now, Poynting works out an equation

4:29

to describe energy flux,

4:32

that is, how much electromagnetic energy

4:34

is passing through an area per second.

4:37

This is known as the Poynting vector

4:39

and it's given the symbol S.

4:41

And the formula is really pretty simple,

4:43

it's just a constant one over mu naught,

4:46

which is the permeability of free space

4:48

times E X B.

4:50

Now, E X B,

4:51

is the cross product

4:52

of the electric and magnetic fields.

4:54

Now, the cross product is just a particular way

4:57

of multiplying two vectors together,

4:59

where you multiply their perpendicular magnitudes

5:01

and to find the direction,

5:04

you put your fingers in the direction of the first vector,

5:06

which in this case is the electric field,

5:08

and curl them in the direction of the second vector,

5:11

the magnetic fields,

5:11

then your thumb points

5:13

in the direction of the resulting vector,

5:15

the energy flux.

5:17

So, what this shows us about light

5:19

is that the energy is flowing perpendicular

5:22

to both the electronic an the magnetic fields.

5:25

And it's in the same direction as the light is traveling,

5:29

so this makes a lot of sense.

5:30

Light carries energy from its source

5:33

out to its destination.

5:37

But the kicker is this,

5:39

Poynting's equation doesn't just work for light,

5:43

it works anytime there are electric

5:46

and magnetic fields coinciding.

5:49

Anytime you have electric and magnetic fields together,

5:52

there is a flow of energy

5:53

and you can calculate using Poynting's vector.

5:58

To illustrate this,

6:00

let's consider a simple circuit

6:01

with a battery and a light bulb.

6:04

The battery by itself has an electric field

6:07

but since no charges are moving,

6:09

there is no magnetic field

6:11

so the battery doesn't lose energy.

6:13

When the battery is connected into the circuit,

6:16

its electric field extends through the circuit

6:19

at the speed of light.

6:20

This electric field pushes electrons around

6:23

so they accumulate on some of the surfaces of the conductors

6:27

making them negatively charged,

6:29

and are depleted elsewhere

6:30

leaving their surfaces positively charged.

6:34

These surface charges

6:36

create a small electric field inside the wires,

6:39

causing electrons to drift

6:41

preferentially in one direction.

6:43

Note that this drift velocity is extremely slow

6:47

around a tenth of a millimeter per second.

6:49

But this is current,

6:51

well, conventional current

6:52

is defined to flow opposite the motion of electrons,

6:55

but this is what's making it happen.

6:58

The charge on the surfaces of the conductors

7:01

also creates an eclectic field outside the wires

7:05

and the current inside the wires

7:07

creates a magnetic field outside the wires.

7:10

So, now there is a combination

7:12

of electric and magnetic fields

7:14

in this space around the circuit.

7:17

So, according to Poynting's theory,

7:19

energy should be flowing

7:21

and we can work out the direction of this energy flow

7:24

using the right hand rule.

7:26

Around the battery for example,

7:27

the electric field is down

7:29

and the magnetic field is into the screen.

7:32

So, you find the energy flux is to the right

7:35

away from the battery.

7:37

In fact, all around the battery,

7:39

you'll find the energy is radially outwards.

7:43

Energy is going out through the sides of the battery

7:47

into the fields.

7:49

Along the wires, again,

7:50

you can use the right hand rule

7:52

to find the energy is flowing to the right.

7:55

This is true for the fields along the top wire

7:58

and the bottom wire.

8:00

But at the filament,

8:00

the Poynting vector is directed in toward the light bulb.

8:04

So, the light bulb is getting energy from the field.

8:08

If you do the cross product,

8:09

you find the energy is coming in from all around the bulb.

8:13

It takes many paths from the battery to the bulb,

8:16

but in all cases,

8:17

the energy is transmitted

8:19

by the electric and magnetic fields.

8:21

- People seem to think that you're pumping electrons

8:24

and that you're buying electrons or something,

8:26

which is just so wrong. (laughs)

8:29

For most people,

8:30

and I think to this day, it's quite counterintuitive

8:32

to think that the energy is flowing through the space

8:35

around the conductor,

8:36

but the energy is,

8:38

which is traveling through the field,

8:39

yeah, is going quite fast.

8:42

- So, there are a few things to notice here.

8:45

Even though the electrons go two ways

8:47

away from the battery and towards it,

8:49

by using the Poynting vector,

8:51

you find that the energy flux only goes one way

8:54

from the battery to the bulb.

8:56

This also shows it's the fields

8:58

and not the electrons that carry the energy.

9:01

- How far do the electrons go

9:03

in this little thing you're talking about,

9:05

they barely move,

9:06

they probably don't move at all.

9:08

- Now, what happens if in place of a battery,

9:10

we use an alternating current source?

9:13

Well then, the direction of current

9:15

reverses every half cycle.

9:17

But this means that both the electric and magnetic fields

9:20

flip at the same time,

9:22

so at any instant,

9:24

the Poynting vector still points in the same direction,

9:27

from the source to the bulb.

9:29

So the exact same analysis we used for DC

9:32

still works for AC.

9:35

And this explains how energy is able to flow

9:37

from power plants to home in power lines.

9:40

Inside the wires,

9:41

electrons just oscillate back and forth.

9:44

Their motion is greatly exaggerated here.

9:47

But they do not carry the energy.

9:49

Outside the wires,

9:50

oscillating eclectic and magnetic fields

9:53

travel from the power station to your home.

9:56

You can use the Poynting vector to check

9:58

that the energy flux is going in one direction.

10:02

You might think this is just an academic discussion

10:05

that you could see the energy as transmitted

10:07

either by fields or by the current in the wire.

10:11

But that is not the case,

10:13

and people learned this the hard way

10:15

when they started laying undersea telegraph cables.

10:18

The first Trans Atlantic cable was laid in 1858.

10:22

- It only worked for about a month,

10:24

it never worked properly.

10:25

- There are all kinds of distortions

10:27

when they try to send signals.

10:28

- Enormous amounts of distortion.

10:30

They could work it at a few words per minute.

10:32

- What they found was sending signals

10:34

over such a long distance under the sea,

10:37

the pulses became distorted and lengthened.

10:40

It was hard to differentiate dots from dashes.

10:43

To account for the failure,

10:45

there was a debate among scientists.

10:47

William Thomson, the future Lord Kelvin,

10:50

thought electrical signals moved through submarine cables

10:53

like water flowing through a rubber tube.

10:56

But others like Heaviside and Fitzgerald,

10:58

argued it was the fields around the wires

11:01

that carried the energy and information.

11:03

And ultimately,

11:05

this view proved correct.

11:07

To insulate and protect the submarine cable,

11:10

the central copper conductor

11:12

had been coated in an insulator

11:13

and then encased in an iron sheath.

11:16

The iron was only meant to strengthen the cable,

11:19

but as a good conductor,

11:20

it interfered with a propagation of electromagnetic fields

11:23

because it increased the capacitance of the line.

11:27

This is why today, most power lines are suspended high up.

11:31

Even the damp earth acts as a conductor,

11:33

so you want a large insulating gap of air

11:36

to separate the wires from the ground.

11:40

So, what is the answer

11:42

to our giant circuit light bulb question?

11:45

Well, after I close the switch,

11:47

the light bulb will turn on almost instantaneously,

11:51

in roughly 1/C seconds.

11:54

So, the correct answer is D.

11:57

I think a lot of people imagine

11:58

that the electric field needs to travel

12:00

from the battery,

12:01

all the way down the wire

12:03

which is a light second long,

12:04

so it should take a second for the bulb to light up.

12:07

But what we've learned in this video

12:09

is it's not really what's happening in the wires

12:12

that matters,

12:13

it's what happens around the wires.

12:16

And the electric and magnetic fields

12:17

can propagate out through space

12:19

to this light bulb,

12:20

which is only one meter away in a few nanoseconds.

12:24

And so, that is the limiting factor

12:27

for the light bulb turning on.

12:29

Now, the bulb won't receive

12:30

the entire voltage of the battery immediately,

12:33

it'll be some fraction,

12:34

which depends on the impedance of these lines

12:37

and the impedance of the bulb.

12:39

Now, I asked several experts about this question,

12:42

and got kind of different answers,

12:44

but we all agreed on these main points.

12:46

So, I'm gonna put their analysis in the description

12:48

in case you want to learn more about this particular setup.

12:52

If I get called out on it

12:53

and people don't think it's real,

12:55

we can definitely invest the resources

12:58

and string up some lines,

12:59

and make our own power lines in the desert.

13:01

- I think you're gonna get called out on it.

13:03

- I agree, I think you're gonna get called out.

13:06

(laughing)

13:09

I think that's right.

13:10

- I think it's just kinda wild

13:12

that this is one of those things

13:14

that we use everyday,

13:16

that almost nobody thinks about

13:18

or knows the right answer to.

13:20

These traveling electromagnetic waves around power lines

13:23

are really what's delivering your power.

13:30

Hey, now that you understand

13:31

how electrical energy actually flows,

13:34

you can think about that

13:34

every time you flick on a light switch.

13:37

And if you want to take your switches to the next level,

13:39

the sponsor of this video, Caseta by Lutron,

13:41

provides premium smart lighting control,

13:43

including switches, remotes, and plug-in smart dimmers.

13:47

And since one switch can control many regular bulbs,

13:50

you can effectively make all those bulbs smart

13:52

just by replacing the switch.

13:54

Then, you can turn your lights on and off

13:56

using your phone,

13:58

or you can use another device

14:00

like Alexa or Google Assistant.

14:02

Caseta works with more leading smart home brands

14:04

than any other smart lighting control system.

14:07

One of the things I like is setting timers.

14:09

The lights in my office for example,

14:10

turn on by themselves every evening.

14:12

And this feature gives you peace of mind

14:14

that everyone in your household

14:15

will always come home to a well-lit house.

14:18

And once you're already in bed,

14:20

you can check which lights you forgot to turn off

14:22

and do that from your phone.

14:23

Installation is easy.

14:25

Make sure you turn off power to the switch first

14:27

and then disconnect the existing wires

14:30

and connect Caseda's smart switch.

14:32

If you need any help,

14:33

they're just a click or a call away.

14:35

Learn more about Caseda at Lutron's website,

14:37

lutron.com/veritasium.

14:39

I will put that link down in the description.

14:41

So, I want to thank Lutron Electronics

14:44

for sponsoring this video,

14:45

and I want to thank you for watching.