PasteQuill

Randy Pausch Last Lecture Transcript

Carnegie Mellon UniversityYouTube captionsEnglish (en)2131 segmentsWatch on YouTube

0:17

>> Make me earn it.

0:24

It's wonderful to be here.

0:27

What Indira didn't tell you is that

0:28

this lecture series used to

0:30

be called The Last Lecture.

0:31

If you had one last lecture to

0:33

give before you died, what would it be?

0:35

I thought, damn, I finally

0:36

nailed the venue, and they renamed it.

0:38

So in case there's

0:42

anybody who wandered in

0:43

and doesn't know the back story.

0:45

My dad always taught me when there's

0:46

an elephant in the room, introduce them.

0:49

If you look at my CT scans, there are

0:51

approximately 10 tumors in my liver,

0:53

and the doctors told me

0:54

3-6 months of good health left.

0:56

That was a month ago, so you can do the math.

0:59

I have some of the best doctors in

1:01

the world. Microphone's not working?

1:08

Then I'll just have to talk louder.

1:11

Is that good? So that is what it is.

1:15

We can't change it, and

1:17

we just have to decide

1:18

how we're going to respond to that.

1:19

We cannot change the cards we are dealt,

1:21

just how we play the hand.

1:23

If I don't seem as

1:25

depressed or morose as I should be,

1:27

sorry to disappoint you.

1:30

And I assure you, I am not in denial.

1:33

It's not like I'm not

1:34

aware of what's going on.

1:35

My family, my three kids,

1:37

my wife, we just decamped.

1:39

We bought a lovely house in Chesapeake,

1:41

Virginia near Norfolk,

1:42

and we're doing that because

1:44

that's a better place for

1:44

the family to be down the road.

1:46

And the other thing is, I am in

1:48

phenomenally good health right now.

1:49

It is the greatest thing

1:51

of cognitive dissonance you will

1:52

ever see is the fact

1:54

that I am in really good shape.

1:56

In fact, I'm in

1:56

better shape than most of you.

2:10

So anybody who wants to cry or pity me can

2:13

come down and do a few of those,

2:15

and then you may pity me.

2:18

So what we're not talking about today.

2:20

We're not talking about cancer,

2:22

because I spent a lot

2:23

of time talking about that,

2:24

and I'm really not interested.

2:25

If you have any herbal supplements

2:26

or remedies, please stay away from me.

2:29

And we're not going to talk

2:31

about things that are even more

2:32

important than

2:33

achieving your childhood dreams.

2:34

We're not going to talk about my wife,

2:35

we're not to talk to

2:36

my kids because I'm good,

2:37

but I'm not good enough to

2:38

talk about that without tearing up.

2:39

So we're just going

2:40

to take that off the table.

2:41

That's much more important. And we're

2:44

not going to talk

2:44

about spirituality and religion.

2:46

Although I will tell you that I have

2:48

experienced a deathbed conversion.

2:50

I just bought a Macintosh.

3:01

Now, I knew I'd get

3:03

9% of the audience with that.

3:06

So what is today's talk about then?

3:08

It's about my childhood dreams

3:10

and how I've achieved them.

3:12

I've been very fortunate that way.

3:14

How I believe I've been able to enable

3:16

the dreams of others.

3:19

And to some degree,

3:21

lessons learned. I'm a professor.

3:22

There should be some lessons

3:23

learned and how you can

3:25

use the stuff you hear today to

3:27

achieve your dreams or

3:29

enable the dreams of others.

3:30

And as you get older, you may find that

3:32

enabling the dreams of

3:33

others thing is even more fun.

3:35

So, what were my childhood dreams?

3:37

Well, I had a really good childhood.

3:40

No kidding around. I was

3:43

going back through the family archives,

3:44

and what was really

3:45

amazing was I couldn't find

3:47

any pictures of me as a kid

3:48

where I wasn't smiling.

3:50

And that was just a very gratifying thing.

3:55

There was our dog.

4:00

And there I actually have a

4:02

picture of me dreaming.

4:05

And I did a lot of that.

4:07

There was a lot of "wake up!"

4:10

And it was an easy time to dream.

4:14

I was born in 1960.

4:17

When you're 8- or 9-years-old,

4:20

and you look at

4:20

the TV set and men are landing on

4:22

the moon, anything is possible.

4:24

And that's something we should

4:26

not lose sight of is

4:28

that the inspiration and

4:30

the permission to dream is huge.

4:32

So what were my childhood dreams?

4:35

You may not agree with this list,

4:36

but I was there.

4:39

Being in zero gravity, playing in

4:41

the National Football League,

4:43

authoring an article in

4:44

the World Book Encyclopedia.

4:45

I guess you can tell the nerds early.

4:48

Being Captain Kirk, anybody here have

4:51

that childhood dream? Not at CMU, no.

4:54

I wanted to become one of

4:56

the guys who won the big stuffed

4:58

animals in the amusement park,

4:59

and I wanted to be an Imagineer with Disney.

5:01

These are not sorted in any particular order,

5:03

although I think they do get harder,

5:05

except for maybe the first one.

5:07

So being in zero gravity.

5:09

Now, it's important to have specific dreams.

5:12

I did not dream of being an astronaut,

5:13

because when I was a little kid,

5:14

I wore glasses, and they told me,

5:15

astronauts can't have glasses, and I was like,

5:17

I didn't really want the whole astronaut

5:18

gig. I just wanted the floating.

5:22

And as a child, Prototype 0.0.

5:29

But that didn't work so well.

5:32

And it turns out that NASA has

5:35

something called the vomit comet

5:37

that they use to train the astronauts.

5:39

And this thing does parabolic arcs.

5:41

And at the top of each arc,

5:43

you get about 25 seconds

5:44

where you're ballistic and you

5:45

get a rough equivalent

5:47

of weightlessness for about 25 seconds.

5:49

And there is a program where

5:51

college students can submit proposals,

5:54

and if they win

5:56

the competition, they get to fly.

5:58

And I thought that was really cool,

6:00

and we had a team and we put a team together,

6:01

and they won and they got to fly.

6:03

And I was all excited

6:04

cause I was going to go with them.

6:06

And then I hit the first brick wall

6:08

because they made it very clear that

6:10

under no circumstances were

6:13

faculty members allowed

6:14

to fly with the teams.

6:16

I know, I was heartbroken. I was like,

6:19

but I worked so hard.

6:23

And so I read the literature very carefully,

6:26

and it turns out that NASA, it's

6:28

part of their outreach and publicity program.

6:31

And it turns out that these

6:32

students were allowed to

6:33

bring a local media

6:35

journalist from their hometown.

6:42

And -- Randy Pausch, web journalist --

6:48

It's really easy to get a press pass.

6:50

So I called up the guys at NASA and I said,

6:53

I need to know where to fax some documents.

6:55

And they said,

6:55

what documents are you going to fax us.

6:57

I said, my resignation

6:58

as the faculty advisor,

6:59

and my application as the journalist.

7:02

And he said, that's a little

7:05

transparent, don't you think?

7:08

And I said, yeah, but

7:10

our project is virtual reality,

7:11

and we're going to bring down

7:12

a whole bunch of VR headsets,

7:14

and all the students from

7:15

all the teams are going to experience it,

7:17

and all those other real journalists

7:19

are going to get to film it.

7:21

Jim Polly's going, ha, you bastard, yes.

7:25

And the guy said, here's the fax number.

7:28

And indeed, we kept our end of the bargain.

7:31

And that's one of

7:32

the themes that you'll hear later on

7:33

the talk is have

7:34

something to bring to the table,

7:35

because that will make you more welcome.

7:38

And if you're curious about

7:40

what zero gravity looks like,

7:42

hopefully the sound will be working here.

7:50

>> It's on.

7:51

>> Go get them, Mazzi. This is fantastic.

7:55

It's just amazing. It's nothing like I

7:58

expected. We're having a great.

8:00

>> Here I am.

8:01

>> I don't think any of us [inaudible].

8:04

This is awesome.

8:09

You got one, [inaudible] Mazzi.

8:12

>> [inaudible], got

8:13

a ball for you [inaudible].

8:17

>> You do pay the piper at the bottom.

8:21

So childhood dream number 1, check.

8:26

Let's talk about football. My dream was

8:28

to play in the National Football League.

8:30

And most of you don't know that - no,

8:34

I did not make it to

8:36

the National Football League.

8:37

But I probably got more from

8:41

that dream and not accomplishing

8:43

it than I got from any

8:44

of the ones that I did accomplish.

8:47

I had a coach. I signed

8:49

up when I was 9-years-old.

8:50

I was the smallest kid in the league by far.

8:53

And I had a coach Jim Graham, who was 6'4".

8:56

He had played linebacker at Penn State.

8:58

He was just this hulk of a guy,

9:01

and he was old school. Really old school.

9:05

He thought the forward pass was a trick play.

9:07

And he showed up for practice the first day.

9:11

And, this big hulking guy,

9:13

we were all scared to death of him.

9:15

And he hadn't brought any footballs.

9:17

How are we going to have practice

9:19

without any footballs?

9:21

And one of the other kids said,

9:23

excuse me, coach, but there's no football.

9:25

And Coach Graham said, right,

9:27

how many men are on a football field at time?

9:29

So we said 11, on a team 22.

9:31

And Coach Graham said, and

9:34

how many people are touching the

9:35

football at any given time?

9:36

One of them. And he said, right.

9:38

So we're gonna work on what

9:39

those other 21 guys are doing.

9:41

And that's a really good story because

9:45

it's all about fundamentals.

9:48

You've got to get the fundamentals down,

9:49

because otherwise, the fancy stuff

9:51

isn't going to work.

9:52

And the other Jim Graham story

9:53

I have is there

9:54

was one practice where he just

9:55

rode me all practice.

9:57

You're doing this wrong,

9:57

you're doing this wrong.

9:58

Go back and do it again. You owe me.

9:59

You're doing pushups after practice.

10:01

And when it was all over, one of

10:02

the other assistant coaches

10:03

came over and said,

10:04

Coach Graham rode you pretty hard, didn't he?

10:07

He said, that's a good thing.

10:09

He said, when you're screwing up

10:11

and nobody's saying anything to you anymore,

10:14

that means they gave up.

10:16

And that's a lesson that stuck with me.

10:19

My whole life is that

10:20

when you see yourself doing something badly,

10:23

and nobody's bothering to tell you anymore,

10:25

that's a very bad place to be.

10:27

Your critics are your ones

10:28

telling you they still love you and care.

10:30

After Coach Graham had

10:31

another coach, Coach Setliff,

10:32

and he taught me a lot about

10:34

the power of enthusiasm.

10:35

He did this one thing where

10:36

only for one play at a time,

10:38

he would put people in at

10:39

the most horrifically

10:41

wrong position for them.

10:42

All the short guys would become receivers.

10:45

It was just laughable, but

10:47

we only went in for one play.

10:50

And boy, the other team

10:52

just never knew what hit them.

10:53

Because when you're only doing it for

10:55

one play and you're just

10:56

not where you're supposed to be,

10:57

and freedom's just another word

10:58

for nothing left to lose,

10:59

boy, are you going to clean

11:00

somebody's clock for that one play.

11:02

And that kind of enthusiasm was great.

11:04

And to this day, I am most

11:05

comfortable on a football field.

11:07

It's just one of those things

11:09

where if I'm working a hard problem,

11:11

people will see me wandering

11:13

the halls with one of these things.

11:14

And that's just because when

11:16

you do something young

11:17

enough and you train for it,

11:18

it just becomes a part of you.

11:20

And I'm very glad that

11:21

football was a part of my life.

11:22

And if I didn't get the dream of

11:24

playing in the NFL, that's okay.

11:26

I probably got stuff more

11:27

valuable because looking

11:28

at what's going on in the NFL,

11:29

I'm not sure those guys

11:30

are doing so great right now.

11:33

And so one of the expressions

11:35

I learned at electronic arts, which I love,

11:37

which pertains to this is experience is

11:39

what you get when you

11:40

didn't get what you wanted.

11:42

And I think that's absolutely lovely.

11:44

And the other thing about football is

11:47

we send our kids out to play football,

11:49

or soccer, or swimming, or whatever it is.

11:51

And it's the first example of what I'm

11:52

going to call

11:53

a head fake or indirect learning.

11:54

We actually don't want

11:55

our kids to learn football.

11:56

It's really nice that I

11:57

have a wonderful three point stance,

11:59

and that know how to do a chop

12:00

block and all this kind of stuff.

12:01

But we send our kids out to

12:03

learn much more important things,

12:05

teamwork, sportsmanship, perseverance, etc.

12:08

And these kinds of head fake learnings

12:11

are absolutely important,

12:13

and you should keep your eye

12:14

out for them because they're everywhere.

12:16

A simple one, being an author

12:18

in the World Book encyclopedia.

12:20

When I was a kid, we had

12:21

the World Book encyclopedia on the shelf,

12:23

for the freshmen, this is paper.

12:28

We used to have these things called books.

12:33

And after I had

12:35

become somewhat of

12:36

an authority on virtual reality,

12:37

but not like a really important one,

12:38

so I was at the level of people

12:40

the World Book would badger.

12:42

They called me up, and I wrote an article,

12:44

and this is Caitlyn Kelleher.

12:46

And there's an article,

12:48

if you go to your local library where

12:49

they still have copies of the World Book.

12:51

Look under V,

12:51

for virtual reality, and there it is.

12:53

And all I have to say is that having

12:56

been selected to be an author

12:58

in the World Book Encyclopedia,

13:00

I now believe that Wikipedia

13:01

is a perfectly fine source for

13:03

your information because I know what

13:04

the quality control is

13:06

for real encyclopedias.

13:07

They let me in. Next one.

13:16

At a certain point, you just realize

13:19

there's some things you're not going to do,

13:20

so maybe you just want to

13:21

stand close to the people.

13:23

And my god,

13:29

what a role model for young people.

13:33

This is everything you want to be.

13:35

And what I learned that carried me forward in

13:38

leadership later is that

13:39

he wasn't the smartest guy on the ship.

13:41

Spock was pretty smart,

13:42

and McCoy was the doctor

13:43

and Scotty was the engineer,

13:45

and you go, and what skill set

13:47

did he have to get on

13:48

this damn thing and run it?

13:49

And clearly, there's

13:51

this skill set called leadership.

13:53

And whether or not you like the series,

13:55

there's no doubt that

13:56

there was a lot to be learned

13:57

about how to lead people by

13:59

watching this guy in action.

14:00

And he just had the coolest damn toys.

14:05

My god, I

14:10

just thought it was fascinating

14:11

as a kid that he had this thing,

14:13

and he could talk to the ship with it.

14:17

I just thought that was just spectacular.

14:20

And, of course, now I own one,

14:22

and it's taller. So that's kinda cool.

14:26

So I got to achieve this dream.

14:33

James T. Kirk, his alter ego,

14:37

William Shatner wrote a book,

14:39

which I think was actually

14:40

a pretty cool book.

14:40

It was with Chip Walter,

14:42

who is a Pittsburgh

14:44

based author who's quite good.

14:45

And they wrote a book on

14:46

basically the Science of Star Trek,

14:48

What Has Come True.

14:49

And they went around to top places around

14:51

the country and looked at various things,

14:53

and they came here to study

14:54

our virtual reality center.

14:55

And so we built a virtual reality for him.

14:58

It looks something like that. We put

15:00

it in, put it to red alert.

15:02

He was a very good sport. It's not

15:03

like he saw that one coming.

15:04

>> [LAUGHTER].

15:06

>> And it's really

15:10

cool to meet your boyhood idol.

15:13

But it's even cooler when

15:15

he comes to you to see

15:17

what cool stuff you're doing in your

15:19

lab. [LAUGHTER].

15:21

That was just a great moment.

15:24

Winning stuffed animals.

15:28

This may seem mundane to you,

15:31

but when you're a little kid, you see

15:32

the big buff guys

15:33

walking around in an amusement park,

15:34

and they got all these big stuffed animals,

15:36

And this is my lovely wife.

15:38

And I have a lot of pictures of

15:40

stuffed animals I've won. [LAUGHTER].

15:43

That's my dad posing with one that I won.

15:46

I've won a lot of these

15:48

animals. [LAUGHTER] There's my dad.

15:50

He did win that one to

15:51

his credit. [LAUGHTER] And this

16:00

was just a big part of

16:01

my life in my family's life.

16:02

But can hear the cynics.

16:05

In this age

16:06

of digitally manipulated things.

16:08

Maybe those bears really

16:10

aren't in the picture with me. [LAUGHTER]

16:12

Or maybe I paid somebody

16:14

five bucks to take a picture in

16:15

the theme park next to the bear.

16:17

And I said, how in this age of

16:18

cynicism can I convince people?

16:20

And I said, I know.

16:22

I can show them the bears.

16:24

[LAUGHTER][APPLAUSE].

16:33

Just put them right there.

16:33

You just put them back against the wall.

16:42

Thanks, honey. [LAUGHTER].

16:48

So, here's some bears.

16:51

We didn't have quite enough room in

16:53

the moving truck down to Chesapeake.

16:55

And anybody who'd like

16:57

a little piece of me at the end of this,

16:59

feel free to come up first come, first served.

17:02

My next one. Being an Imagineer.

17:05

This was the hard one. Believe me,

17:09

getting to zero gravity is

17:10

easier than becoming an Imagineer.

17:12

When I was a kid, I was eight years old,

17:15

and our family took a trip cross

17:17

country to see Disneyland.

17:18

And if you ever seen

17:20

the movie National Lampoon's vacation,

17:22

it was a lot like that. [LAUGHTER].

17:24

Because there's a quest.

17:26

And these are real vintage photographs.

17:30

And there I am in front of the castle.

17:35

And there I am and for

17:36

those of you who are into foreshadowing,

17:38

this is the Alice Ride. [LAUGHTER].

17:41

And I just thought this was

17:43

just the coolest environment

17:46

I've ever been in.

17:47

And instead of saying, Gee,

17:48

I want to experience this,

17:48

I said, I want to make stuff like this.

17:51

And so I bided my time,

17:53

and then I graduated with my Ph.D. from

17:55

Carnegie Mellon thinking that meant

17:56

me infinitely qualified to do anything.

17:58

And I dashed off my letters of

17:59

application to Walt Disney Imagineering,

18:01

and they sent me some of the

18:02

damn nicest go to

18:03

hell letters I've ever gotten. [LAUGHTER].

18:09

We have carefully reviewed

18:10

your application, and presently,

18:12

we do not have any positions

18:14

available which require

18:15

your particular qualifications.

18:18

Now, think about the fact that you're getting

18:19

this from a place that's famous for

18:21

guys who sweep the streets. [LAUGHTER].

18:25

So that was a bit of a setback.

18:27

But remember, the brick walls

18:30

are there for a reason.

18:31

The brick walls are not there to keep us out.

18:33

The brick walls are there to give us a chance

18:36

to show how badly we want something,

18:39

because the brick walls are there to stop

18:40

the people who don't want it badly enough.

18:43

They're there to stop the other

18:45

people. [LAUGHTER].

18:49

Fast forward to 1991,

18:51

we did a system back at

18:51

University of Virginia called

18:52

Virtual Reality on $5 a day.

18:55

Just one of those

18:56

unbelievable spectacular things.

18:58

I was so scared

19:00

back in those days as a junior academic.

19:02

Jim Foley's here, and I

19:03

just love to tell the story.

19:04

He knew my undergraduate advisor,

19:06

Andy Van Dam.

19:07

And I'm at my first conference,

19:08

and I'm just scared to death.

19:09

And this icon in

19:11

the user Interface Community

19:12

walks up to me and just out of nowhere,

19:14

just gives me this huge bear hug,

19:15

and he says, That was from Andy.

19:17

And that was when I thought, ok,

19:19

maybe I can make it.

19:21

Maybe I do belong.

19:24

And a similar story is that this was

19:26

just this unbelievable hit

19:27

because at the time,

19:27

everybody needed a half a

19:28

million dollars to do virtual reality,

19:30

and everybody felt frustrated.

19:31

And we literally hacked

19:32

together a system for about

19:33

$5,000 in parts and made a working VR system.

19:37

And people were just like, oh my god.

19:38

It's like the Hewlett Packard garage thing.

19:40

This is so awesome.

19:41

And so I'm giving this talk and

19:42

the room has just gone wild.

19:44

And during the Q&A a guy named Tom Furness,

19:46

who was one of the big names

19:47

in virtual reality at the time,

19:49

he goes up to

19:49

the microphone and introduces himself.

19:50

I didn't know what he looked like,

19:51

but I sure as hell knew the name.

19:53

And he asked a question.

19:54

And I was like, I'm sorry. Did you

19:55

say you're Tom Furness?

19:57

He said, yes, I said, then

19:59

I would love to answer

20:00

your question, but first,

20:01

will you have lunch

20:02

with me tomorrow? [LAUGHTER]

20:05

And there's a lot in that little moment.

20:08

There's a lot of humility,

20:09

but also asking a person where he

20:11

can't possibly say no. [LAUGHTER].

20:19

And so imagineering, a couple of years later,

20:22

was working on a virtual reality project.

20:24

This was top secret.

20:25

They were denying the existence of

20:27

a virtual reality attraction after

20:29

the time that the Publicity Department

20:31

was running the TV commercials.

20:32

So imagineering really had

20:34

nailed this one tight.

20:36

And it was the Aladdin attraction

20:38

where you would fly a magic carpet.

20:40

And the head mounted display,

20:41

sometimes known as Gator vision.

20:43

And so I had an in.

20:46

As soon as the project had just,

20:49

they started running the TV commercials.

20:50

And I had been asked to brief

20:53

the Secretary of Defense

20:54

on the state of virtual reality.

20:55

Fred Brooks and I

20:57

had been asked to brief

20:59

the Secretary of Defense.

21:00

And that gave me an excuse.

21:04

So I called them up.

21:06

I called the imagineering and I said, look,

21:07

I'm briefing the Secretary of Defense.

21:08

I'd like some materials on what you have,

21:10

because it's one of

21:11

the bestVR systems in the world.

21:12

And they kind of

21:13

pushed back and I said, look,

21:14

is all this patriotism stuff

21:15

in the parks a farce?

21:19

They said, this is

21:22

so new the PR department

21:23

doesn't have any footage for you.

21:24

So I'm going to have to connect you straight

21:26

through to the team who did the work.

21:27

Jackpot. So I find

21:30

myself on the phone with

21:31

a guy named Jon Snoddy,

21:32

who is one of the most

21:33

impressive guys I have ever met.

21:36

And he was the guy running this team,

21:37

and it's not surprising they

21:38

had done impressive things.

21:39

And so he sent me some stuff.

21:42

We talked briefly,

21:42

sent me some stuff and I said,

21:43

I'm going to be out in the area

21:45

for a conference shortly,

21:46

would you like to get together to have lunch.

21:48

Translation. I'm going to lie to

21:50

you and say that

21:51

I have an excuse to be in the area,

21:52

so I don't look too anxious.

21:54

But I would go to

21:55

Neptune to have a lunch with

21:56

you. [LAUGHTER] And so Jon said, sure.

22:01

And I spent something like

22:05

80 hours talking with

22:07

all the VR experts in the world,

22:09

saying, if you had access to

22:10

this unbelievable project,

22:12

what would you ask?

22:13

And then I compiled

22:15

all of that and I had to memorize it,

22:16

which anybody knows me and knows

22:17

that I have no memory at all,

22:18

because I couldn't go in looking like

22:19

a dweeb with Hi,

22:20

question 72.

22:22

So I went in

22:24

and this was like a two hour lunch.

22:26

And Jon must have thought he was talking

22:28

to some phenomenal person because all

22:31

I was doing was channeling Fred Brooks and

22:33

Ivan Sutherland and Andy Van Dam people

22:35

like that, and Henry Fuchs.

22:36

So it's pretty easy to be

22:37

smart when you're parroting smart people.

22:40

And at the end of the lunch with Jon,

22:43

I sort of as we say in the business, made the ask.

22:46

And I said, I have a sabbatical coming up.

22:50

And he said, what's that? [LAUGHTER].

22:57

The beginnings of the culture clash.

23:00

And so I talked to him about

23:02

the possibility of coming

23:03

there and working with him.

23:05

And he said, well, that's really good,

23:09

except you're in the business

23:11

of telling people stuff,

23:12

and we're in the business of keeping secrets.

23:14

And then what made Jon Snoddy Jon Snoddy was, he said,

23:17

but we'll work it out, which I really loved.

23:20

The other thing that I

23:21

learned from Jon Snoddy,

23:22

I could easily do an hour-long talk

23:23

just on what have I learned from Jon Snoddy.

23:25

One of the things he told me was

23:26

that wait long enough,

23:28

and people will surprise and impress you.

23:30

He said, when you're pissed off at

23:31

somebody and you're angry at them,

23:33

you just haven't given them enough time.

23:35

Just give them a little more time,

23:37

and they'll almost always impress you.

23:38

And that really stuck with me. I think

23:39

he's absolutely right on that one.

23:41

So, to make a long story short,

23:44

we negotiated a legal contract.

23:48

It was going to be the first.

23:49

Some people referred to it as

23:50

the first and last paper

23:51

ever published by Imagineering.

23:53

But the deal was, I go, I

23:55

provide my own funding, I go for six months.

23:57

I work with a project, we publish a paper.

23:59

And then we meet our villain.

24:04

I can't be all sweetness and light,

24:06

because I have no credibility.

24:07

Somebody's head's going to go on a stick.

24:10

Turns out that the person who

24:11

gets his head on the stick is

24:12

a dean back at the University of Virginia.

24:14

His name is not important.

24:15

Let's call him Dean Wormer. [LAUGHTER].

24:23

And Dean Wormer

24:24

has a meeting with me where I say,

24:26

I want to do the sabbatical thing,

24:27

and I've actually

24:27

gotten the Imagineering guys

24:28

to let an academic in, which is insane.

24:30

If Jon hadn't gone nuts,

24:32

this would never been a possibility he is

24:33

a very secretive organization.

24:35

And Dean Wormer looks

24:36

at the paperwork and he says,

24:37

well, says they're going to

24:38

own your intellectual property.

24:39

I said, we got the agreement to publish

24:40

the paper. There is no other IP.

24:42

I don't do patentable stuff.

24:44

He says, yeah, but you might.

24:45

So the deals off, get

24:46

them to change that little clause there.

24:48

And then come back to me. I was

24:52

like, excuse me.

24:54

And then I said to him, I want

24:56

you to understand how important this is.

24:57

If we can't work this out,

24:59

I'm going to take an unpaid leave of absence,

25:01

and I'm just going to go there,

25:03

and I'm going to do this thing.

25:06

And he said, hey,

25:08

I might not even let you do that.

25:10

You've got the IP in your head already,

25:12

and maybe they're going to

25:12

suck it out of you,

25:13

so that's not going to fly either. [LAUGHTER].

25:21

It's very important to

25:22

know when you're in a pissing match.

25:25

And it's very important to get out

25:27

of it as quickly as possible.

25:28

So I said to him, well,

25:30

let's back off on this.

25:32

Do we think this is a good idea at all?

25:34

He said, I have

25:35

no idea if this is a good idea.

25:36

I was

25:38

like well, ok, we've got common ground there.

25:40

And I said, well, is this really your call?

25:42

Isn't this the call of the dean

25:44

of sponsored research?

25:45

If it's an IP issue, and he

25:46

said, yeah, that's true.

25:48

I said, so if he's happy, you're happy?

25:49

Then I'd be fine. [NOISE] Like

25:51

Wile E. Coyote a little. [LAUGHTER].

25:53

And I find myself in Gene Block's office,

25:54

who is the most fantastic man in the world.

25:56

And I start talking to Gene Block, and I say,

25:57

Let's start at the high level, since

25:59

I don't want to have to back out again.

26:00

Let's start at the high level.

26:01

Do you think this is a good idea?

26:02

He said, well,

26:03

if you're asking me if it's a good idea,

26:05

I don't have very much information.

26:06

All I know is that one of my star

26:07

faculty members is in my office,

26:08

and he's really excited, so tell me more.

26:10

Here's a lesson for

26:11

everybody in administration.

26:12

They both said the same thing.

26:15

But think about how they said

26:18

it. I don't know.

26:21

Well, I don't have much information,

26:23

but one of my star faculty members is here,

26:25

and he's all excited,

26:26

so I want to learn more.

26:27

They are both ways of saying,

26:28

I don't know, but,

26:29

boy, there's a good way and a bad way.

26:31

So anyway, we got it all worked out.

26:34

I went to Imagineering, sweetness and light,

26:36

and all's well that ends well. [LAUGHTER].

26:42

Some brick walls are made of flesh. [LAUGHTER].

26:46

So I worked on the Aladdin project.

26:48

It was absolutely spectacular,

26:51

just unbelievable.

26:53

Here's my nephew Christopher.

26:55

This was the apparatus.

26:56

You would sit on this motorcycle type thing,

26:58

and you would steer your magic carpet,

27:00

and you would put on

27:01

the head mounted display.

27:03

The head mounted display is very interesting.

27:04

It had two parts, and it was

27:05

a very clever design to

27:06

get throughput through, the only part that

27:08

touched the guests head was this little cap,

27:09

and everything else clicked onto

27:10

it, all the expensive hardware.

27:11

So you could replicate the caps because they

27:13

were basically free to manufacture.

27:15

And this is what I really did,

27:18

as I was a cap cleaner during this matter.

27:22

I loved Imagineering.

27:24

It was just a spectacular place.

27:27

Everything that I had dreamed.

27:29

I loved the model shop.

27:30

People crawling around on things the size of

27:33

this room that are just big physical models.

27:35

It was just an incredible place to

27:37

walk around and be inspired.

27:39

I'm always reminded when I went there,

27:42

and people said, do you think

27:43

the expectations are too high?

27:44

And I said, you ever see the movie

27:46

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory?

27:47

Willie Wonka and the Chocolate Factory,

27:48

where Gene Wilder says to the little boy

27:50

Charlie he's about to

27:50

give him the chocolate factory.

27:51

He says, well, Charlie, did

27:53

anybody ever tell you the story of

27:54

the little boy who suddenly

27:56

got everything he ever wanted?

27:58

Charlie's eyes get like saucers,

28:00

and he says, no, What happened to him?

28:03

Gene Wilder says, he

28:05

lived happily ever after. [LAUGHTER].

28:08

So working on the Aladdin VR,

28:10

I described it as a once in

28:11

every five years opportunity,

28:12

and I stand by that assessment.

28:14

It forever changed me.

28:16

It wasn't just that it was good work

28:17

and I got to be a part of it.

28:19

But it got me into the place of working with

28:22

real people and real

28:23

HCI user interface issues.

28:25

Most HCI people live in this fantasy world of

28:28

white collar laborers with

28:29

Ph.D.s and master's degrees.

28:31

And until you've got

28:32

ice cream spilled on you,

28:33

you're not doing field work.

28:36

And more than anything else from Jon Snoddy,

28:39

I learned how to put artists

28:40

and engineers together.

28:41

And that's been the real legacy.

28:43

We published a paper,

28:44

just a nice academic cultural scandal.

28:46

When we wrote the paper,

28:47

the guys at Imagineering said,

28:48

well, let's do a nice, big picture.

28:51

Like you would in a magazine.

28:53

And the Siggraph Committee,

28:54

which accepted the paper,

28:55

was like this big scandal.

28:56

Are they allowed to do that? [LAUGHTER].

28:58

There was no rule.

29:02

So we published the paper,

29:04

and amazingly, since then,

29:06

there's a tradition of Siggraph papers

29:07

having colored figures on the first page.

29:10

So I've changed the world in a small way.

29:12

[LAUGHTER].

29:14

And then at the end of my six months,

29:17

they came to me and they said,

29:18

you want to do it for real?

29:20

You can stay. [LAUGHTER]. And I said, no.

29:29

One of the only times in my life I

29:30

have surprised my father.

29:31

He was like, you what?

29:34

He said, since you were,

29:36

all you wanted, and now they got it in there.

29:40

There was a bottle of Maalox in my desk drawer.

29:42

Be careful what you wish for.

29:44

It was a particularly stressful place.

29:45

Imagineering in general is

29:46

actually not so Maalox laden,

29:48

but the lab I was in,

29:49

Jon left in the middle.

29:51

And it was a lot like the Soviet Union.

29:54

It was a little dicy for a while.

29:57

But it worked out okay.

29:58

And if they had said,

30:00

stay here or never walk in

30:01

the building again, I would have done it.

30:03

I would have walked away from

30:05

tenure, I would have just done it.

30:06

But they made it easy on me.

30:08

They said you can have

30:09

your cake and eat it too,

30:10

and I basically become

30:10

a day a week consultant for Imagineering,

30:13

and I did that for about 10 years.

30:14

And that's one of the reasons

30:16

you should all become professors.

30:18

Because you can have

30:19

your cake and eat it too.

30:21

I went on and

30:23

consulted on things like Disney Quest.

30:25

So there was the virtual Jungle Cruise.

30:26

And the best interactive experience,

30:29

I think ever done,

30:29

and Jesse Schell gets the credit for this.

30:31

Pirates of the Caribbean.

30:33

Wonderful at Disney Quest.

30:36

And so those are my childhood dreams.

30:38

And that's pretty good.

30:40

I felt good about that.

30:41

So then the question becomes,

30:42

how can I enable

30:44

the childhood dreams of others?

30:45

And again, boy, am I

30:47

glad I became a professor.

30:49

What better place to enable childhood dreams?

30:54

Maybe you're working at EA, I don't know.

30:56

That probably is a good close second.

31:02

This started in a very

31:04

concrete realization that

31:06

I could do this because

31:08

a young man named Tommy Burnett,

31:09

when I was at the University of Virginia,

31:10

came to me was interested in

31:11

joining my research group,

31:13

and we talked about it,

31:15

and he said, and I have a childhood dream.

31:16

Well, it gets pretty easy to

31:18

recognize them when they tell you.

31:20

And I said, Yes,

31:21

Tommy, what is your childhood dream?

31:23

He said, I want to work on the

31:24

next Star Wars film.

31:27

Now, you got to remember the timing

31:29

on this. Where is Tommy?

31:30

Tommy is here today? What year would

31:32

this have been? Your sophomore year?

31:35

>> [BACKGROUND].

31:36

>> Are you breaking anything back there,

31:37

young man? So in 1993.

31:40

And I said to Tommy, you know they're

31:43

probably not going to make those next movies.

31:50

And he said, no, they are.

31:58

And Tommy worked with me for

32:01

a number of years as an

32:02

undergraduate and then as a staff member,

32:04

and then when I moved to Carnegie Mellon,

32:05

every single member of my team came

32:08

from Virginia to Carnegie Mellon,

32:10

except for Tommy

32:11

because he got a better offer.

32:13

And he did indeed work

32:15

on all three of those films.

32:19

And then I said, Well, that's nice,

32:21

but, one at a time is kind of inefficient.

32:24

People who know me know that I'm

32:26

an efficiency freak.

32:27

So I said, can I do this in mass?

32:29

Can I get people turned in

32:31

such a way that they can be turned

32:33

onto their childhood dreams?

32:34

And I came to

32:36

Carnegie Mellon and I created a course

32:37

called Building Virtual World.

32:38

It's a very simple course.

32:40

How many people have ever

32:41

been to any of the shows?

32:43

Some of you have an idea, for those of you

32:45

don't, the course is very simple.

32:46

There are 50 students drawn from

32:48

all the different departments

32:49

of the university.

32:50

There are randomly chosen teams,

32:54

four people per team,

32:56

and they change every project.

32:57

A project only lasts two weeks,

32:59

so you do something, you make something,

33:01

you show something, then I shuffle the teams,

33:03

you get three new playmates,

33:05

and you do it again.

33:06

And it's every two weeks,

33:08

and so you do

33:09

five projects during the semester.

33:11

The first year we taught this course,

33:13

it is impossible to

33:15

describe how much of

33:16

a tiger by the tail we had.

33:19

I was just running the course

33:20

because I wanted to see if we could do it.

33:22

We had just learned how to do texture

33:23

mapping on 3D graphics,

33:24

and we could make stuff

33:25

that looked half decent,

33:26

but we were running on

33:27

really weak computers by current standards.

33:30

But I said, I'll give it a try.

33:32

And at my new university,

33:33

I made a couple of phone calls and I said,

33:35

I want to cross list

33:35

this course to get all other people,

33:37

and within 24 hours it was

33:38

cross listed in five departments.

33:40

I love this university.

33:42

It's the most amazing place.

33:45

And I said the kids said,

33:46

well, what content do we make?

33:47

I said, hell, I don't know.

33:48

You make whatever you want.

33:50

Two rules: no

33:52

shooting violence and no pornography.

33:54

Not because I'm opposed

33:55

to those in particular,

33:57

but, that's been done with VR.

34:01

And you'd be amazed how

34:03

many 19-year-old boys are

34:04

completely out of ideas

34:06

when you take those off the table.

34:12

Anyway, so I taught the course.

34:15

The first assignment,

34:16

I gave it to them,

34:17

they came back in two weeks,

34:18

and they just blew me away.

34:21

The work was so

34:22

beyond literally my imagination,

34:25

because I copied the process

34:26

from Imagineerings VR Lab,

34:28

but I had no idea

34:29

what they could or couldn't do with it

34:30

as undergraduates because

34:32

their tools were weaker.

34:33

And they came back in the first assignment,

34:35

and they did something that was so

34:36

spectacular that I literally,

34:38

10 years as a professor I had no idea what to

34:40

do next. So I called up my mentor.

34:42

I called up Andy Van Dam. And I said, Andy,

34:47

I just gave a two week assignment,

34:48

and they came back and did stuff that if

34:49

I'd given them a whole semester,

34:51

I would have given them all A's.

34:52

Sensei, what do I do?

34:56

And Andy thought for a minute and he said,

34:59

you go back into class tomorrow,

35:02

and you look them in the eye and you say,

35:04

guys, that was pretty good,

35:06

but I know you can do better.

35:11

And that was exactly the right advice,

35:13

because what he said was,

35:14

you obviously don't know

35:16

where the bar should be,

35:18

and you're only going to do them

35:19

a disservice by putting it anywhere.

35:22

And boy, was that good advice,

35:25

because they just kept going.

35:28

And during that semester,

35:29

it became this underground thing.

35:31

I'd walk into a class with 50 students in it,

35:34

and there were 95 people in the room.

35:38

Because it was the day we

35:39

were showing work and

35:41

people's roommates and friends and parents.

35:44

I'd never had parents come to class before.

35:47

It was flattering and somewhat scary.

35:50

And so it snowballed

35:52

and we had this bizarre thing of,

35:53

we got to share this.

35:54

If there's anything I've been raised

35:56

to do, it's to share.

35:57

And I said, we got to show this semester.

35:59

We got to have a big show. And we

36:01

booked this room, McConomy,

36:02

I have a lot of good memories in this room,

36:03

And we booked it not

36:04

because we thought we could fill it,

36:05

but because it had

36:06

the only AV setup that would work,

36:08

because this was a zoo,

36:10

computers and everything.

36:12

And then we filled it.

36:14

And we more than filled it.

36:16

We had people standing in the aisle.

36:17

I will never forget the dean at the time

36:19

Jim Morris was sitting on

36:20

the stage right about there.

36:22

We had to scoot him out of the way.

36:25

And the energy in the room

36:27

was like nothing I

36:28

had ever experienced before.

36:29

And President Jerry Cohon,

36:31

was there and he sensed the same thing.

36:34

He later described it as like an

36:35

Ohio State football pep rally,

36:37

except for academics.

36:39

And he came over

36:41

and he asked exactly the right question.

36:43

He said before you start,

36:43

he said, I got to know,

36:45

where are these people from?

36:47

He said, the audience.

36:48

What departments are they from?

36:49

And we polled them and it

36:49

was all the departments.

36:51

And I felt very good because

36:53

I had just come to campus.

36:54

He had just come to campus,

36:56

and my new boss had seen in

36:58

a very corporeal way that this is

37:00

the university that puts everybody together.

37:03

And that made me feel just tremendous.

37:06

So we did this campus- wide exhibition.

37:08

People performed down here.

37:09

They were in costume,

37:10

and we project just like this,

37:12

and you can see what's going on.

37:13

You can see what

37:14

they're seeing in the head mount.

37:16

There's a lot of big props, so there's

37:17

a guy whitewater rafting.

37:20

This is then ET.

37:25

And yes, I did tell them

37:27

if they didn't do the shot of

37:28

the kids biking across the moon,

37:29

I would fail him.

37:30

That is a true story. So I

37:38

thought I'd show you just one world.

37:39

And if we get the lights down,

37:40

if that's at all possible?

37:42

No. That means no.

37:45

We'll just do our best then.

37:49

>> Hello, there. I'm lonely.

37:54

Make me a new world.

39:24

>> Now, they're going to

39:26

turn this on its head.

39:27

Watch closely.

39:28

The world doesn't want to

39:30

go on to the next thing in the show.

39:32

So she's ready to move on, and it's not.

39:40

>> What are you doing?

39:43

>> [BACKGROUND].

39:45

>> But there are so many other

39:47

worlds that have to go.

39:48

>> But our world is the best world.

40:00

>> I'm going to shut you down.

40:09

Control alt delete

40:51

>> Don't

41:05

control alt delete.

41:11

>> We love you.

41:29

>> It was an unusual course.

41:34

With some of the most brilliant,

41:36

creative students from all across the campus,

41:39

it just was a joy to be involved.

41:42

And they took

41:43

the whole stage performance aspect

41:44

of this way too seriously.

41:48

And it became this

41:50

campus phenomenon every year.

41:52

People would line up for it.

41:54

It was very flattering.

41:56

And it gave kids a chance of a sense of

41:59

excitement of putting on a show

42:01

for people who were then excited about it.

42:03

And I think that that's one

42:05

of the best things you can give somebody,

42:06

the chance to show them what it feels like

42:09

to make other people get

42:10

excited and happy, that's a tremendous gift.

42:13

We always tried to involve the audience,

42:14

whether it was people with glow sticks

42:16

or batting a beach ball

42:17

around or driving. This is really cool.

42:21

This technology actually got used at

42:22

the Spider Man 3 premiere in LA,

42:24

so the audience was controlling

42:26

something on the screen, so that's nice.

42:28

And I don't have a

42:30

class picture from every year,

42:32

but I dredged all the ones that I do have.

42:33

And all I can say is

42:34

that what a privilege and an

42:36

honor it was to teach

42:37

that course for something like 10 years.

42:39

And all good things come to an end,

42:44

and I stopped teaching

42:45

that course about a year ago.

42:47

People always ask me,

42:48

what was my favorite moment?

42:49

I don't know if you could have

42:50

a favorite moment,

42:51

but boy, there's one I'll never forget.

42:54

This was a world with,

42:56

I believe, a rollerskating ninja.

42:58

And one of the rules was that

43:00

we performed these things live,

43:01

and they all had to really work,

43:02

and the moment it stopped working,

43:04

we went to your backup videotape.

43:05

And this was very embarrassing.

43:08

So we have this ninja on stage.

43:10

He's doing this rollerskating thing,

43:11

and the world it did not crash gently.

43:14

And I come out and I

43:16

believe it was Steve Audio, wasn't it?

43:18

Is it? Where is he? Here's Steve.

43:21

My man, Steve Audio. And talk

43:24

about quick on your feet.

43:26

I say, Steve, I'm sorry, but

43:27

your world has crashed,

43:29

and we're going to go to videotape.

43:31

And he pulls out his ninja sword and says,

43:35

I am dishonored and just drops.

43:47

And so I think it's very telling that

43:49

my favorite moment in

43:51

10 years of this high technology course

43:53

was a brilliant ad lib,

43:55

and then when the videotape

43:56

was done, and the lights come up,

43:58

he's lying there lifeless,

43:59

and his teammates drag him off.

44:02

It was really a fantastic moment.

44:07

And the course was all about bonding.

44:10

People used to say,

44:11

what's going to make for a good world?

44:12

I said, I can't tell you beforehand,

44:13

but right before they present it,

44:15

I can tell you if the world's

44:16

good just by the body language.

44:18

If they're standing close to each

44:19

other, the world is good.

44:21

And BVW was a pioneering course.

44:25

And, I won't bore you with all the details,

44:32

but it wasn't easy to do.

44:35

And I was given this

44:37

when I stepped down from the ETC,

44:38

and I think it's emblematic.

44:40

If you're going to

44:40

do anything that's pioneering,

44:42

you will get those arrows in the back,

44:43

and you just have to put up with it.

44:45

Everything that could go wrong did go wrong,

44:47

but at the end of the day,

44:49

a whole lot of people had a whole lot of fun.

44:52

When you've had something for

44:54

10 years that you hold so precious,

44:57

it's the toughest thing in

44:58

the world to hand it over.

45:00

And the only advice I can give you

45:01

is find somebody better

45:03

than you to hand it

45:04

to, and that's what I did.

45:06

There was this kid

45:08

at the VR studio way back when,

45:11

and you didn't have to spend very long in

45:12

Jesse Schell's orbit to go,

45:14

force is strong in this one.

45:17

And one of my two greatest accomplishments,

45:20

I think for Carnegie Mellon were that I got

45:22

Jessica Hodgins and Jesse Schell

45:24

to come here and join our faculty,

45:25

and I was thrilled when I could

45:26

hand this over to Jesse,

45:27

and to no one's surprise,

45:29

he has really taken it up to the next notch.

45:31

And the course is in more than good hands.

45:34

It's in better hands.

45:36

But it was just one course.

45:39

And then we really took it up a notch.

45:42

And we created what I would

45:44

call the Dream Fulfillment Factory.

45:47

Don Marinelli and I got together,

45:49

and with the university's

45:51

blessing and encouragement,

45:52

we made this thing out of

45:54

whole cloth that was absolutely insane,

45:56

should never have been tried.

45:58

All the sane universities

46:01

didn't go near this kind of stuff,

46:03

creating a tremendous opportunistic void.

46:07

So the Entertainment Technology

46:09

Center was all about artists and

46:10

technologists working in

46:12

small teams to make things.

46:13

It was

46:13

a two-year professional master's degree,

46:16

and Don and I were two kindred spirits.

46:19

We're very different. Anybody who knows

46:20

us knows that we're very different people.

46:23

And we like to do things in a new way.

46:26

And the truth of the matter

46:27

is that we're both a

46:28

little uncomfortable in academia.

46:30

I used to say that I'm

46:31

uncomfortable as an academic because

46:32

I come from a long line of people

46:33

who actually worked for a living.

46:35

So, I detect nervous laughter.

46:44

And I want to stress Carnegie Mellon is

46:46

the only place in the world

46:47

that the ETC could have happened,

46:48

by far, the only place.

46:54

This picture was Don's idea.

46:58

And we like to refer to this picture

47:01

as Don Marinelli on

47:02

guitar and Randy Pausch on keyboard.

47:06

But we really did play up

47:08

the left brain right brain,

47:09

and it worked out really well that way.

47:11

Don is an intense guy.

47:19

And Don and I shared an office.

47:24

And at first, it was a small office.

47:26

We shared an office for six years.

47:30

Now, those of you who know

47:32

Don know he's an intense guy.

47:34

And, given my current condition,

47:36

somebody was asking me,

47:38

this is a terrible joke,

47:39

but I'm going to use it

47:39

anyway because I know Don will forgive me.

47:43

Somebody said, given your current condition,

47:45

have you thought about

47:46

whether you're going to

47:46

go to heaven or hell?

47:48

And I said, I don't know,

47:50

but if I'm going to hell,

47:51

I'll do six years for time served.

47:54

I kid. Sharing an office

47:57

with Don was really like sharing

47:59

an office with a tornado.

48:00

There was just so much energy,

48:02

and you never knew which trailer was next.

48:05

But you knew something

48:07

exciting was going to happen.

48:09

And there was so much energy.

48:12

And I do believe in

48:13

giving credit where credit is due.

48:15

So in my typically visual way,

48:17

if Don and I were to split

48:19

the success for the ETC,

48:20

he clearly gets the lion's share of it.

48:22

He did the lion's share of the work.

48:24

He had the lion's share of the ideas.

48:25

It was a great teamwork.

48:27

I think it was a great yin and yang,

48:28

but it was more like Ying and Yang.

48:31

And he deserves that credit,

48:32

and I give it to him

48:33

because the ETC is a wonderful place.

48:36

And, he's now running it,

48:38

and he's taking it global,

48:39

we'll talk about that in a second.

48:40

Describing the ETC is really hard,

48:42

and I finally found a metaphor.

48:44

Telling people about the ETC,

48:46

is it like describing Cirque Du

48:47

Soleil if they'd never seen it.

48:49

Sooner orlater,

48:50

you're going to make the mistake.

48:51

You're going to say, Well,

48:51

it's like a circus.

48:52

And then you're

48:53

dragged into this conversation

48:54

about, Oh, how many tigers?

48:55

How many lions? How many trapeze acts?

48:57

And that misses the whole point.

48:59

So when we say we're a master's degree,

49:00

we're really not like

49:01

any master's degree you've ever seen.

49:03

Here's the curriculum.

49:10

The curriculum ended up looking like this.

49:13

All I want to do is

49:13

visually communicate to you that you do

49:15

five projects in building

49:16

virtual words, then you do three more.

49:18

All of your time is spent in

49:19

small teams making stuff.

49:21

None of that book learning thing.

49:23

Don and I had

49:23

no patience for the book learning thing.

49:25

It's a master's degree. They already spent

49:26

four years doing book learning,

49:28

by now, they should have read all the books.

49:32

The keys to success were that

49:35

Carnegie Mellon gave us the reins.

49:38

Completely gave us the reins.

49:40

We had no deans to report to,

49:41

we reported directly to the provost,

49:43

which is great because the provost is way

49:44

too busy to watch you carefully.

49:47

We were given explicit license

49:49

to break the mold.

49:50

It was all project based. It was intense.

49:52

It was fun, and we took field trips.

49:54

Every spring semester in January,

49:56

we'd take all 50

49:57

students in the first-year class,

49:59

and we'd take them out the shops like Pixar,

50:00

we'd take them to

50:01

Pixar Industrial Lite Magic.

50:02

And, of course, when you got guys like

50:03

Tommy there acting as host,

50:06

it's pretty easy to get

50:07

entree to these places.

50:08

So we did things very differently.

50:11

The kind of project students would do we did

50:13

a lot of what we'd call edutainment.

50:16

We developed a bunch of things with

50:17

the Fire Department of New York,

50:19

a network simulator for

50:20

training firefighters,

50:21

using video gamish type technology to

50:23

teach people useful things. That's not bad.

50:26

Companies did this strange thing.

50:29

They put in writing.

50:29

We promise to hire your students.

50:32

I've got the EA and Activision ones here.

50:35

I think there are now how many five?

50:38

Drew knows, I bet. So there

50:41

are five written agreements.

50:42

I don't know of any other school that has

50:43

this kind of

50:44

written agreement with any company.

50:46

And so that's a real statement.

50:47

And these are multiple year things.

50:48

So they're agreeing to hire people for summer

50:50

internships that we have not admitted yet.

50:52

That's a pretty strong statement

50:54

about the quality of the program.

50:55

And Don, as I said, he's crazy.

50:59

I mean, in a wonderful complimentary way.

51:01

He's doing these things where I'm

51:02

like, Oh, my god.

51:04

He's not here tonight because he's in

51:06

Singapore because there's going to

51:08

be an ETC campus in Singapore.

51:10

There's already one in Australia,

51:11

and there's going to be one in Korea.

51:13

So this is becoming a global phenomenon.

51:15

So I think this really

51:16

speaks volumes about

51:17

all the other universities.

51:17

It's really true that Carnegie Mellon

51:19

is the only university can do this.

51:20

We just have to do it all over the world now.

51:24

One of the big successes about the ETC

51:27

is teaching people about focus.

51:29

Oh, no, I hear

51:30

the nervous laughter from the students.

51:33

I had forgotten the delayed shock

51:36

therapy effect of these bar charts.

51:38

When you're taking Building Virtual

51:39

Worlds, every two weeks,

51:41

we get peer feedback,

51:42

we put that all into a big spreadsheet.

51:43

And at the end of the semester,

51:44

you've had three teammates

51:46

per project five projects,

51:47

that's 15 data points that's

51:48

statistically valid.

51:49

And you get a bar chart telling

51:51

you on a ranking of

51:52

how easy you are to work with where you

51:54

stack up against your peers.

51:56

Boy, that's hard feedback to ignore.

51:59

Some still managed but for the most part,

52:06

people looked at that and went, Wow,

52:08

I got to pick it up a notch.

52:10

I better start thinking about what

52:11

I'm saying to people in these meetings.

52:12

And that is the best gift

52:14

an educator can give is to get

52:15

somebody to become self reflective.

52:18

So the ETC was wonderful, but even the ETC,

52:21

and even as Don scales it around the globe,

52:23

it's still very labor intensive.

52:26

It's not Tommy one at a time.

52:28

It's not a research group, 10 at a time.

52:30

It's 50 or 100

52:32

at a time per campus times four campuses.

52:34

But I wanted something infinitely scalable.

52:38

Scalable to the point where

52:40

millions or tens of millions of

52:41

people could chase

52:43

their dreams with something.

52:44

And I guess that kind of

52:46

a goal really does make me the Mad Hatter.

52:49

So, Alice is a project

52:53

that we've worked on for a long, long time.

52:55

It's a novel way

52:56

to teach computer programming.

52:58

Kids make movies and games.

53:00

The head fake. Again, we're

53:01

back to the head fakes.

53:02

Best way to teach somebody

53:04

something is to have them think they're

53:05

learning something else.

53:07

I've done it my whole career.

53:09

And the head fake here is

53:10

that they're learning to program,

53:11

but they just think they're making

53:12

movies and video games.

53:13

This thing has already been downloaded

53:14

well over a million times.

53:15

There are eight textbooks

53:16

written about it.

53:17

10% of U.S. colleges are using it now.

53:20

And it's not the good stuff yet.

53:22

The good stuff is coming in the next version.

53:26

I, like Moses, get to see the Promised Land,

53:30

but I won't get to set foot in it.

53:32

And that's okay, because I can see it,

53:35

and the vision is clear.

53:37

Millions of kids having fun

53:40

while learning something hard.

53:43

That's pretty cool.

53:45

I can deal with that as a legacy.

53:46

The next version is going to

53:48

come out in 2008,

53:48

it's going to be teaching the Java language,

53:50

if you want them to

53:51

know they're learning Java?

53:52

Otherwise, they'll just think

53:53

that they're writing movie scripts.

53:55

And we're getting the characters

53:59

from the best selling PC game

54:01

in history, the Sims.

54:02

And this is all already working in the lab.

54:04

So there's no real technological risk.

54:06

I don't have time to thank and

54:08

mention everybody in the Alice team,

54:09

but I just want to say that Dennis Cosgrove

54:11

is going to be building this,

54:12

has been building this.

54:13

He is the designer. It's his baby.

54:15

And for those here are wondering,

54:18

well, in some number of months,

54:20

who should I be

54:21

emailing about the Alice project?

54:22

Where's Wanda Dann? There you are.

54:25

Stand up. Let them all see you.

54:27

Everybody say, Hi, Wanda.

54:29

>> Hi Wanda.

54:31

>> Send her the email. And I'll

54:35

talk a little bit

54:35

more about Caitlin Kelleher,

54:36

but she's graduated with

54:37

her Ph.D. and is at Washington University,

54:40

and she's going to be taking this up

54:41

a notch and going to middle schools with it.

54:43

So grand vision, and,

54:46

to the extent that you can

54:47

live on in something,

54:48

I will live on in Alice.

54:50

So now the third part of

54:52

the talk, lessons learned.

54:53

And we've talked about my dreams.

54:55

We've talked about helping

54:56

other people in living their dreams.

54:58

Somewhere along the way, there's

54:59

got to be some aspect of

55:00

what lets you get to achieve your dreams.

55:04

First one is the role of parents,

55:06

mentors and students.

55:08

I was blessed to

55:11

have been born to two incredible people.

55:13

This is my mother on her 70th birthday.

55:16

I am back here.

55:18

I have just been lapped. This is

55:23

my dad riding a roller coaster

55:24

on his 80th birthday.

55:26

And he points out that, you know,

55:29

he's not only brave,

55:30

he's talented because he did

55:32

win that big bear the same day.

55:34

My dad was so full of life.

55:38

Anything with him was an adventure.

55:40

I don't know what's in that bag,

55:41

but I know it's cool.

55:44

My dad dressed up as Santa Claus,

55:47

but he also did

55:49

very significant things to

55:52

help lots of people.

55:53

This is a dormitory in Thailand

55:55

that my mom and dad underwrote,

55:57

and every year, about 30 students

56:00

get to go to school who

56:01

wouldn't have otherwise.

56:02

So my wife and I have also

56:03

been involved in heavily.

56:04

And these are the kind of things that I

56:06

think everybody ought to

56:08

be doing helping others.

56:10

But the best story about my dad is

56:12

unfortunately my dad passed

56:13

away a little over a year ago.

56:14

And when we were going through his things,

56:16

he had fought in

56:17

World War II in the Battle of the Bulge.

56:19

And when we were going through his things,

56:20

we found out he had been awarded

56:21

the Bronze Star for

56:22

Valor. My mom didn't know it.

56:26

In 50 years of marriage,

56:28

it had just never come up.

56:32

My mom. Mothers are

56:35

people who love you even

56:35

when you pull their hair.

56:38

And I have two great mom stories.

56:41

When I was here studying to get my Ph.D.,

56:43

and I was taking something

56:44

called the theory qualifier,

56:46

which I can definitively say is

56:48

the second worst thing

56:49

in my life after chemotherapy.

56:53

And I was complaining to my mother about how

56:57

hard this test was and how awful it was.

57:00

And she just leaned over

57:01

and she patted me on the arm,

57:02

and she said, we know how you feel,

57:03

honey, and remember,

57:04

when your father was your age,

57:05

he was fighting the Germans.

57:13

After I got my Ph.D.,

57:16

my mother took great relish in

57:17

introducing me as, this is my son.

57:19

He's a doctor, but not

57:20

the kind who helps people.

57:26

These slides are a little bit dark,

57:28

but when I was in high school,

57:29

I decided to paint my bedroom.

57:31

I'd always wanted

57:32

a submarine and an elevator.

57:35

And the great thing about

57:36

this, What can I say?

57:44

And the great thing about this

57:46

is they let me do it.

57:47

And they didn't get upset about it,

57:49

and it's still there.

57:51

If you go to

57:51

my parents' house, it's still there.

57:53

And anybody who's out there who is a parent,

57:55

if your kids want to paint their

57:56

bedroom, as a favor to me,

57:59

let them do it. It'll be okay.

58:01

Don't worry about resale value on the house.

58:05

Other people who helped

58:07

us besides our parents.

58:08

Our teachers, our mentors,

58:09

our friends, our colleagues.

58:11

God. What is there to say about Andy Van Dam?

58:15

When I was a freshman at Brown,

58:16

he was on leave.

58:17

And all I heard about was this Andy Van Dam.

58:20

He was like a mythical creature,

58:22

like a centaur, but, like,

58:23

a really pissed off centaur.

58:25

And everybody was like,

58:28

really sad that he was gone,

58:29

but kind of more relaxed.

58:33

And I found out why because

58:35

I started working for Andy.

58:36

I was a teaching assistant

58:37

for him as a sophomore.

58:38

And I was quite an arrogant young man.

58:40

And I came in to some office hours,

58:43

and, of course, it was nine o'clock at night,

58:45

and Andy was there at office hours,

58:46

which is your first clue as to

58:47

what kind of professor he was.

58:49

And I come bounding in,

58:51

and I'm just I'm going to save the world.

58:53

There are all these kids waiting for help.

58:55

And afterwards, Andy literally Dutch uncle.

58:58

He is Dutch. He Dutch uncled me.

59:00

And he put his arm around my shoulders.

59:01

We went for a little walk,

59:02

and he said, Randy,

59:03

it's such a shame

59:06

that people perceive you as so arrogant.

59:10

Because it's going to

59:13

limit what you're going

59:14

to be able to accomplish in life.

59:17

What a hell of a good way to

59:19

word you're being a jerk.

59:22

He doesn't say you're a jerk. He says,

59:24

People are perceiving you

59:25

this way and he says,

59:25

the downside is it's going to limit what

59:27

you're going to be able to accomplish.

59:30

When I got to know Andy better,

59:32

the beatings became more direct.

59:33

But I could tell

59:38

you Andy stories for a month.

59:40

But the one I will tell you

59:41

is that when it came time to

59:42

start thinking about what to do after

59:43

graduating from Brown,

59:44

it had never occurred to me in

59:45

a million years to go to graduate school,

59:47

just out of my imagination.

59:48

Wasn't the kind of thing people

59:49

from my family did.

59:51

We got, say what do you call them ... jobs.

59:53

So Andy said, No,

59:57

don't go do that. Go get a Ph.D.

59:58

Become a professor. I said, Why?

60:00

He said, Because you're

60:03

such a good salesman that any company

60:06

who gets you is going to

60:07

use you as a salesman,

60:08

and you might as well be

60:10

selling something worthwhile, like education.

60:18

Thanks. Andy was my first boss, so to speak.

60:25

I was lucky enough to have a lot of bosses.

60:28

That red circle was way off.

60:30

Als over here.

60:31

I don't know what the hell happened there.

60:35

He's probably watching us on the webcast

60:37

going, My god, he's targeting.

60:38

And he still can't aim.

60:41

I don't want to say much

60:43

about the great bosses

60:44

I've had, except that they were great.

60:46

And I know a lot of people in

60:47

the world have had bad bosses,

60:49

and I haven't had to endure that experience,

60:51

and I'm very grateful to all of

60:52

the people that I ever had to report to.

60:54

They've just been incredible.

60:56

But it's not just our bosses.

60:57

We learn from our students.

60:58

I think the best head fake of

61:00

all time come from Dr. Caitlin Kelleher.

61:04

Who just finished up here,

61:06

starting at Washington University.

61:08

And she looked at Alice

61:09

when it was an easier way

61:10

to learn the program.

61:11

And she said, Yeah, but, why is that fun?

61:13

I was like, because I'm a compulsive male,

61:16

like to make

61:17

the little toy soldiers move around by

61:18

my command and that's fun. She was like, Hmm.

61:23

And she was the one who said, No,

61:25

we'll just approach it all

61:26

as a storytelling activity.

61:27

And she's done wonderful work showing that,

61:30

particularly with middle school girls,

61:32

if you present it as a storytelling activity,

61:33

they're perfectly willing to

61:35

learn how to write computer software.

61:36

So all time best head fake award

61:40

goes to Caitlin Kelleher's dissertation.

61:43

President Cohon, when I

61:45

told him I was going to do

61:46

this talk, he said,

61:47

"Please tell them about having fun because

61:50

that's what I remember you for."

61:54

And I said, "I can do that, but it's like

61:56

a fish talking about

61:57

the importance of water."

61:58

I don't know how to not have fun.

62:01

I'm dying and I'm having fun.

62:05

And I'm going to keep having fun every

62:08

day I have left

62:10

because there's no other way to play it.

62:12

So my next piece of advice is,

62:15

you just have to decide

62:17

if you're a Tigger or you're an Eeyore.

62:19

I think I'm clear where I

62:21

stand on the great Tigger or Eeyore debate.

62:26

Never lose the child-like wonder.

62:29

It's just too important.

62:31

It's what drives us.

62:33

Help others. Denny Proffitt

62:36

knows more about helping other people.

62:38

He's forgotten more than I'll ever know.

62:40

He's taught me by example how to run a group,

62:43

how to care about people.

62:44

MK Haley, I have

62:45

a theory that people who come from

62:46

large families are better people

62:48

because they've just had to

62:49

learn how to get along.

62:50

MK Haley comes from a family with 20 kids.

62:55

Unbelievable. And she always says,

62:58

it's fun to do the impossible.

62:59

When I first got to Imagineering,

63:01

she was one of the people

63:02

who dressed me down.

63:03

And she said, "I

63:05

understand you've

63:05

joined the Aladdin project,

63:06

what can you do?"

63:07

And I said, "Well, I'm a tenured professor

63:09

of computer science."

63:10

And she said, "Well, that's very nice,

63:12

Professor Boy, but that's not what I asked.

63:14

I said, what can you do?"

63:15

[LAUGHTER] And I mentioned

63:24

my working class roots.

63:27

We keep what is valuable to us,

63:29

what we cherish, and I've kept

63:31

my letterman's jacket all these years.

63:32

I used to like wearing it in grad school.

63:35

And one of my friends,

63:36

Jessica Hodgins would say,

63:38

"Why do you wear this letterman's jacket?"

63:40

And I looked around at all the

63:42

non-athletic guys around me,

63:43

who were much smarter than me, and I

63:44

said, "Because I can."

63:46

[LAUGHTER] And so she

63:49

thought that was the real hoot.

63:51

So one year she made for me

63:52

this little Raggedy Randy doll.

63:54

He's got a little letterman's jacket, too.

63:57

That's my all- time favorite.

63:59

It's the perfect gift for

64:00

the egomaniac in your life.

64:03

I've met so many

64:06

wonderful people along the way.

64:08

Loyalty is a two-way street.

64:10

There was a young man named Dennis Cosgrove

64:12

at the University of Virginia.

64:14

When he was a young man,

64:17

let's just say things happened.

64:21

And I found myself talking to a dean.

64:25

And the dean, no,

64:27

not that dean, anyway,

64:31

this dean really had it in for Dennis,

64:32

and I can never figure why because

64:33

Dennis was a fine fellow.

64:34

But for some reason,

64:34

this dean really had it in for him.

64:36

And I ended up basically saying, "No,

64:37

I vouch for Dennis."

64:38

And the guy says, "You're

64:39

not even tenured yet,

64:40

and you're telling me you're going to

64:42

vouch for

64:43

this sophomore or junior or whatever."

64:45

I think he was a junior at the time. I said,

64:47

" Yeah, I'm going to vouch for him

64:47

because I believe in him."

64:48

And the dean said, " And I'm going to

64:50

remember this when

64:51

your tenure case comes up."

64:52

And I said, "Deal." I went

64:55

back to talked to Dennis and I said,

64:56

"I would really appreciate you.

64:59

That would be good."

65:01

But loyalty is a two-way street. That was

65:03

god knows how many years ago,

65:05

but that's the same Dennis Cosgrove

65:08

who's carrying Alice forward.

65:10

He's been with me all these years.

65:12

And if we only had one person to

65:15

send in a space probe to meet

65:16

an alien species, I'm picking Dennis.

65:21

You can't give a talk

65:22

at Carnegie Mellon without

65:23

acknowledging one very special person,

65:26

and that would be Sharon Burks.

65:28

And I joked with her.

65:30

I said, "Well look, if you're retiring,

65:31

it's just not worth living anymore."

65:33

[LAUGHTER] Sharon is so

65:38

wonderful, it's beyond description.

65:39

And for all of us who've been helped by

65:41

her, it's just indescribable.

65:43

I love this picture because it

65:44

puts her together with Syl.

65:46

And Syl is great because

65:47

Syl gave the best piece of advice,

65:50

pound for pound that I have ever heard.

65:52

And I think all young

65:53

ladies should hear this.

65:55

Syl said, "It took me a long time,

65:57

but I finally figured it out.

65:58

When it comes to men

66:01

that are romantically interested in you,

66:03

it's really simple, just

66:05

ignore everything they

66:06

say and only pay attention to what they do.

66:10

It's that simple. It's that easy."

66:14

And I thought back to my bachelor days,

66:16

and I said, "Damn."

66:21

Never give up. I didn't

66:24

get into Brown University.

66:25

I was on the wait list.

66:27

I called them up, and they eventually

66:30

decided that it was getting

66:32

really annoying to have me call

66:33

every day, so they let me in.

66:35

At Carnegie Mellon, I didn't

66:37

get into graduate school.

66:38

Andy, he had mentored me.

66:39

He said, "Go to graduate school.

66:40

You're going to go to Carnegie Mellon.

66:41

All my good students go to Carnegie Mellon,

66:43

and you know what's coming."

66:46

And so he said, "You're going to go

66:48

to Carnegie Mellon, no problem."

66:49

What he had forgotten was that

66:51

the difficulty of getting

66:52

into the top Ph.D. program in

66:54

the country had freely gone up,

66:56

and he also didn't know I was going to tank

66:57

my GREs because he believed in me,

67:01

which based on my board scores

67:02

was a really stupid idea.

67:04

And so I didn't get into Carnegie Mellon.

67:06

No one knows this till

67:07

today I'm telling the story,

67:08

I was declined admission to Carnegie Mellon.

67:10

And I was a bit of an obnoxious little kid.

67:15

I went into Andy's office and I

67:17

dropped the rejection letter on his desk.

67:19

And I said, "I just want you

67:20

to know what your letter

67:21

of recommendation

67:22

goes for at Carnegie Mellon."

67:23

[LAUGHTER] And before the letter

67:33

had hit his desk,

67:35

his hand was on the phone,

67:36

and he said, "I will fix this."

67:42

And I said, "No.

67:44

I don't want to do it that way.

67:45

That's not the way I was raised.

67:47

Maybe some other graduate schools

67:48

we'll see fit to admit me."

67:51

And he said, "Look,

67:52

Carnegie Mellon is where

67:53

you are going to be."

67:53

He said, "I tell you what,

67:53

I'll make you a deal,

67:54

go visit the other schools."

67:55

Because I did get into the other schools.

67:56

He said, "Go visit the other schools,

67:58

and if you really don't

67:59

feel comfortable at any of them,

68:00

then well you will let me call Nico."

68:02

Nico being Nico Habermann.

68:03

And I said, "Okay, deal."

68:05

I went to

68:05

the other schools without naming them

68:07

by name; Berkeley, Cornell.

68:10

They managed to be so

68:12

unwelcoming that I

68:13

found myself saying to Andy,

68:15

"I'm going to go get a job."

68:16

And he said, "No, you're not."

68:18

And he picked up the phone,

68:19

and he talked in Dutch.

68:23

And he hung up the phone and he said,

68:26

"Nico says if you're serious

68:28

be in his office tomorrow morning at 8:00

68:29

A.M." And for those of you know Nico,

68:35

this is really scary.

68:37

So I'm in Nico Habermann's office

68:38

the next morning at 8:00 A.M,

68:40

and he's talking with me.

68:41

And frankly, I don't think he's

68:42

that keen on this meeting

68:43

again. I don't think he's that keen at all.

68:46

And he says, "Randy, why are we here?"

68:51

And I said, "Because Andy phoned you."

68:56

And I said, "Well,

68:59

since you admitted me,

69:01

I have won a fellowship."

69:02

The Office of Naval Research

69:05

is a very prestigious fellowship.

69:06

I've won this fellowship, and that

69:07

wasn't in my file when I applied.

69:09

And Nico said, "Fellowship money,

69:12

we have plenty of money." That was back then.

69:16

And he said, "We have plenty of money.

69:19

Why do you think having a fellowship

69:21

makes any difference to us?"

69:22

And he looked at me, there are

69:24

moments that change your life,

69:26

and 10 years later,

69:27

if you know in retrospect,

69:29

it was one of those moments,

69:30

you're blessed, but to know it at

69:33

the moment with Nico

69:36

staring through your soul.

69:39

And I said, "I didn't mean to

69:41

imply anything about the money.

69:42

It's just that it was an honor.

69:44

There were only 15 given nationwide.

69:46

And I did think it was an honor that would

69:47

be something that would be meritorious.

69:49

And I apologize if that was presumptuous."

69:53

And he smiled. And that was good.

69:57

So how do you get people to help you?

70:00

You can't get there alone.

70:01

People have to help you and

70:03

I do believe in Karma. I believe in paybacks.

70:05

You get people to help you by telling

70:07

the truth, being earnest.

70:09

I'll take an earnest person over

70:10

a hip person every day.

70:12

Because hip is short term,

70:13

earnest is long term.

70:15

Apologize when you screw up

70:17

and focus on other people, not on yourself.

70:21

And I thought, How do I possibly

70:23

make a concrete example of that?

70:26

Do we have a concrete example of

70:27

focusing on somebody else over there?

70:28

Can we bring it out?

70:31

See yesterday was my wife's birthday.

70:33

If there was ever a time I

70:36

might be entitled to have the focus on me,

70:38

it might be the last lecture,

70:40

but no, I feel very badly that

70:42

my wife didn't really get a proper birthday,

70:44

and I thought it'd be very nice if 500 people

70:47

[APPLAUSE]

71:06

Happy birthday to you.

71:09

Her name is Jay. Happy birthday to you.

71:14

Happy birthday dear Jay.

71:18

Happy birthday to you.

71:22

[APPLAUSE] You

71:30

got to blow it out.

71:39

All right.

71:41

[APPLAUSE]

71:51

And now y'all have an extra

71:52

reason to come to the reception.

71:55

Remember brick walls let

71:58

us show our dedication.

71:59

They are there to separate us from

72:01

the people who don't really

72:03

want to achieve their childhood dreams.

72:05

Don't bail; the best of

72:07

the gold is at the bottom of barrels of crap.

72:08

[LAUGHTER] What Steve didn't

72:18

tell you was the big sabbatical at EA.

72:20

I'd been there for 48 hours

72:23

and they loved the ETC.

72:25

We were the best, we were the favorites.

72:26

And then somebody else

72:28

pulled me aside and said, "Oh,

72:29

by the way, we're about to give

72:30

$8 million to USC

72:32

to build a program just like yours.

72:33

And we're hoping you could help

72:33

them get it off the ground."

72:39

And then Steve came along and said,

72:42

"They said what? Oh, god."

72:44

And to quote a famous man,

72:47

"I will fix this." And he did.

72:50

Steve has been an incredible partner,

72:52

and we have a great relationship

72:53

personal and professional,

72:55

and he has certainly been point man on

72:58

getting a gaming asset

73:00

to help teach millions of kids,

73:02

and that's just incredible.

73:04

But it certainly would have been

73:06

reasonable for me to leave

73:08

48 hours into that sabbatical,

73:10

but it wouldn't have

73:11

been the right thing to do.

73:13

And when you do the right thing,

73:14

good stuff has a way of happening.

73:18

Get a feedback loop and listen to it.

73:21

Your feedback loop can be

73:22

this dorky spreadsheet thing I did

73:23

or it can just be one great man

73:25

who tells you what you need to hear.

73:27

The hard part is the listening to it.

73:29

Anybody can get chewed out.

73:31

It's the rare person who says, "Oh,

73:33

my god, you were right."

73:34

As opposed to, "No, wait.

73:35

The real reason is." We've all heard that.

73:38

When people give you feedback,

73:39

cherish it and use it. Show gratitude.

73:43

When I got tenure, I took all of

73:44

my research team down

73:46

to Disney World for a week.

73:48

And one of

73:48

the other professors at Virginia said,

73:50

"How can you do that?"

73:51

And he said,

73:52

"These people just busted their a***s and

73:54

got me the best job in the world for life.

73:55

How could I not do that?"

73:58

Don't complain; just work harder.

74:02

Here's a picture of Jackie Robinson who was

74:04

in his contract not to complain,

74:05

even when the fans spit on him.

74:09

Be good at something; it makes

74:12

you valuable. Work hard.

74:15

I got tenure

74:16

a year earlier as Steve mentioned,

74:17

Junior faculty members used to say to me,

74:19

"Wow, you got tenure early,

74:20

what's your secret?"

74:22

And I said, "It's pretty simple.

74:23

Call me any Friday night in my

74:24

office at 10 o'clock and I'll tell you."

74:27

Find the best in everybody.

74:29

One of the things that

74:30

Jon Snoddy, as I said,

74:31

told me is that you

74:33

might have to wait a long time,

74:34

sometimes years, but people

74:36

will show you their good side.

74:38

Just keep waiting no

74:41

matter how long it takes.

74:43

No one is all evil.

74:44

Everybody has a good side.

74:46

Just keep waiting, it will come out.

74:47

And be prepared. Luck is

74:49

truly where preparation meets opportunity.

74:52

So today's talk was

74:54

about my childhood dreams,

74:56

enabling the dreams of others,

74:58

and some lessons learned.

75:01

But did you figure out the head fake?

75:06

It's not about how to achieve your dreams,

75:08

it's about how to lead your life.

75:11

If you lead your life the right way,

75:13

the karma will take care of itself.

75:15

The dreams will come to you.

75:17

Have you figured out the second head fake?

75:20

This talk's not for you; it's for my kids.

75:26

Thank you all. Good night. [APPLAUSE]